• Latest
  • Trending

Livemint says India’s official GDP data includes non-existing firms

May 10, 2019
Iranaitivu residents protest against COVID-19 burials

Iranaitivu residents protest against COVID-19 burials

March 3, 2021
Image credits - Sangga Rima Roman Selia / Unsplash

Global CO2 emissions bounce back to pre-COVID levels, study finds

March 3, 2021
Image credits - Tasnim News Agency; Mohammad Hassanzadeh

Iran’s only female Olympic medallist to compete under white flag in Tokyo

March 3, 2021
Image credits - Neven Krcmarek / Unsplash

Maezawa wants you: Japan billionaire seeks ‘crew’ for moon trip

March 3, 2021
Image credits - Dan Freeman / Unsplash

Australian economy storms ahead as COVID recovery turns ‘V-shaped’

March 3, 2021
Image credits - Hassan Ali @RealHa55an / Twitter

Cricket kind of gets forgotten in IPL; PSL, LPL more rewarding: Dale Steyn

March 3, 2021
Image credits - Hakan Nural / Unsplash

New data show vaccines reduce severe COVID-19 in older adults

March 3, 2021
COVID body being brought for cremation in Sri Lanka

Sri Lankan government to go ahead with Iranaitivu Island for COVID-19 deceased burials

March 3, 2021
Lanka takes three crucial decisions to garner Indian and Muslim support in UNHRC

Lanka takes three crucial decisions to garner Indian and Muslim support in UNHRC

March 2, 2021
Image credits - DNA

Jack Ma loses title as China’s richest man after coming under Beijing’s scrutiny

March 2, 2021
Hope India votes in favour of Sri Lanka at UNHRC: Sri Lanka’s Foreign Secretary Jayanath Colombage

Hope India votes in favour of Sri Lanka at UNHRC: Sri Lanka’s Foreign Secretary Jayanath Colombage

March 3, 2021
A conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952)

A conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952)

March 2, 2021
  • About Us
  • Advertisements
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
Wednesday, March 3, 2021
  • Login
  • Register
No Result
View All Result
NewsIn.Asia
  • Home
  • Around South Asia
    • All
    • Afghanistan
    • Bangladesh
    • Bhutan
    • China
    • India
    • Maldives
    • Myanmar
    • Nepal
    • Pakistan
    • Sri Lanka
    Iranaitivu residents protest against COVID-19 burials

    Iranaitivu residents protest against COVID-19 burials

    Image credits - Hakan Nural / Unsplash

    New data show vaccines reduce severe COVID-19 in older adults

    COVID body being brought for cremation in Sri Lanka

    Sri Lankan government to go ahead with Iranaitivu Island for COVID-19 deceased burials

    Lanka takes three crucial decisions to garner Indian and Muslim support in UNHRC

    Lanka takes three crucial decisions to garner Indian and Muslim support in UNHRC

    Hope India votes in favour of Sri Lanka at UNHRC: Sri Lanka’s Foreign Secretary Jayanath Colombage

    Hope India votes in favour of Sri Lanka at UNHRC: Sri Lanka’s Foreign Secretary Jayanath Colombage

    Lankan government chooses Iranaitivu island to bury COVID-19 dead

    Lankan government chooses Iranaitivu island to bury COVID-19 dead

    Image credits - Mufid Majnun / Unsplash

    Tokyo asks China to stop anal swab tests for COVID-19 on Japanese citizens

    Image credits - Instagram: ICC

    Virat Kohli joins Ronaldo, Messi in an elite list, becomes 1st cricketer with 100 million Instagram followers

    Disciplined societies may have tackled COVID better, but there is a downside in all

    China, U.S. should lift COVID-19 travel bans if herd immunity reached, Chinese epidemiologist says

  • World
    • All
    • Japan
    • Russia
    • United States
    Image credits - Sangga Rima Roman Selia / Unsplash

    Global CO2 emissions bounce back to pre-COVID levels, study finds

    Image credits - Tasnim News Agency; Mohammad Hassanzadeh

    Iran’s only female Olympic medallist to compete under white flag in Tokyo

    Image credits - Neven Krcmarek / Unsplash

    Maezawa wants you: Japan billionaire seeks ‘crew’ for moon trip

    Image credits - Dan Freeman / Unsplash

    Australian economy storms ahead as COVID recovery turns ‘V-shaped’

    Image credits - Mufid Majnun / Unsplash

    Tokyo asks China to stop anal swab tests for COVID-19 on Japanese citizens

    Image credits - Mark Paton / Unsplash

    One in four people will have hearing problems by 2050: WHO

    Disciplined societies may have tackled COVID better, but there is a downside in all

    China, U.S. should lift COVID-19 travel bans if herd immunity reached, Chinese epidemiologist says

    Image credits - Torstensimon

    Fauci urges Americans to get any of the three COVID-19 vaccines available

    Image credits - Joshua Sukoff / Unsplash

    Saudi crown prince approved operation to capture or kill Khashoggi: US intelligence report

  • Business
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Gaming
    • Movie
    • Music
    • Series
    Image credits - Joe Shlabotnik / Flickr

    Key winners at the 2021 Golden Globes

    Image credits - Gage Skidmore

    Chadwick Boseman Wins Best Actor at 2021 Golden Globes for Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom

    The film, a tale of an adolescent boy fighting human-eating demons, has amassed $313 million since opening on Oct. 16. © Koyoharu Gotoge/Shueisha, Aniplex, ufotable

    Japan anime movie ‘Demon Slayer’ lands in US cinemas

    Bengali Adhunik song Bela Hole Absan

    Bengali Adhunik song Bela Hole Absan

    Image credits - Steven Cordes / Unsplash

    Gotta catch ’em all: Pandemic sends prices soaring for Pokemon cards

    Image credits - Fixelgraphy / Unsplash

    Spotify to expand into more than 80 new markets including Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Maldives

    Image credits - AdamBMorgan / big-ashb

    Grammy-winning duo Daft Punk announces split after 28 years

    Image credits - LupEnd007 / rodrigoferrari

    Kim Kardashian files for divorce from Kanye West

    Nollywood meets Bollywood in love tale ‘Namaste Wahala’

    Nollywood meets Bollywood in love tale ‘Namaste Wahala’

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health
    • Science
    • Travel
    Iranaitivu residents protest against COVID-19 burials

    Iranaitivu residents protest against COVID-19 burials

    Image credits - Neven Krcmarek / Unsplash

    Maezawa wants you: Japan billionaire seeks ‘crew’ for moon trip

    Image credits - Mark Paton / Unsplash

    One in four people will have hearing problems by 2050: WHO

    Disciplined societies may have tackled COVID better, but there is a downside in all

    China, U.S. should lift COVID-19 travel bans if herd immunity reached, Chinese epidemiologist says

    Image credits - Slash Gear

    Nestle expands plant-based products with new vegan KitKat bar

    India-made COVID-19 vaccine in Ghana

    India-made COVID-19 vaccine in Ghana

    Image credits - Stefan Spassov / Unsplash

    Japan appoints ‘minister of loneliness’ to help people home alone

    Image credits - freestocks / Unsplash

    Singapore trials Smartphone app offering mini check-ups

    First human case of H5N8 bird flu reported in Russia. Image credits - CDC

    First human case of H5N8 bird flu reported in Russia

    Image credits - LupEnd007 / rodrigoferrari

    Kim Kardashian files for divorce from Kanye West

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
  • Tech
    Image credits - Benjamin Raffetseder / Unsplash

    China’s Xiaomi adds manufacturing muscle in India to boost phone production

    Image credits - freestocks / Unsplash

    Singapore trials Smartphone app offering mini check-ups

    Image credits - Fixelgraphy / Unsplash

    Spotify to expand into more than 80 new markets including Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Maldives

    Image credits - Nicole de Andrade

    Tech Tips: Signal lets users create groups with up to 1000 members, here is how to create one

    Whatsapp / Pic - India Today

    WhatsApp to switch off messages for all who reject new terms

    Image credits - Solen Feyissa / Unsplash

    Facebook news goes dark in Australia as content spat escalates

    Trending Tags

    • Sillicon Valley
    • Climate Change
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
    • Golden Globes
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Mr. Robot
  • Coronavirus
  • Home
  • Around South Asia
    • All
    • Afghanistan
    • Bangladesh
    • Bhutan
    • China
    • India
    • Maldives
    • Myanmar
    • Nepal
    • Pakistan
    • Sri Lanka
    Iranaitivu residents protest against COVID-19 burials

    Iranaitivu residents protest against COVID-19 burials

    Image credits - Hakan Nural / Unsplash

    New data show vaccines reduce severe COVID-19 in older adults

    COVID body being brought for cremation in Sri Lanka

    Sri Lankan government to go ahead with Iranaitivu Island for COVID-19 deceased burials

    Lanka takes three crucial decisions to garner Indian and Muslim support in UNHRC

    Lanka takes three crucial decisions to garner Indian and Muslim support in UNHRC

    Hope India votes in favour of Sri Lanka at UNHRC: Sri Lanka’s Foreign Secretary Jayanath Colombage

    Hope India votes in favour of Sri Lanka at UNHRC: Sri Lanka’s Foreign Secretary Jayanath Colombage

    Lankan government chooses Iranaitivu island to bury COVID-19 dead

    Lankan government chooses Iranaitivu island to bury COVID-19 dead

    Image credits - Mufid Majnun / Unsplash

    Tokyo asks China to stop anal swab tests for COVID-19 on Japanese citizens

    Image credits - Instagram: ICC

    Virat Kohli joins Ronaldo, Messi in an elite list, becomes 1st cricketer with 100 million Instagram followers

    Disciplined societies may have tackled COVID better, but there is a downside in all

    China, U.S. should lift COVID-19 travel bans if herd immunity reached, Chinese epidemiologist says

  • World
    • All
    • Japan
    • Russia
    • United States
    Image credits - Sangga Rima Roman Selia / Unsplash

    Global CO2 emissions bounce back to pre-COVID levels, study finds

    Image credits - Tasnim News Agency; Mohammad Hassanzadeh

    Iran’s only female Olympic medallist to compete under white flag in Tokyo

    Image credits - Neven Krcmarek / Unsplash

    Maezawa wants you: Japan billionaire seeks ‘crew’ for moon trip

    Image credits - Dan Freeman / Unsplash

    Australian economy storms ahead as COVID recovery turns ‘V-shaped’

    Image credits - Mufid Majnun / Unsplash

    Tokyo asks China to stop anal swab tests for COVID-19 on Japanese citizens

    Image credits - Mark Paton / Unsplash

    One in four people will have hearing problems by 2050: WHO

    Disciplined societies may have tackled COVID better, but there is a downside in all

    China, U.S. should lift COVID-19 travel bans if herd immunity reached, Chinese epidemiologist says

    Image credits - Torstensimon

    Fauci urges Americans to get any of the three COVID-19 vaccines available

    Image credits - Joshua Sukoff / Unsplash

    Saudi crown prince approved operation to capture or kill Khashoggi: US intelligence report

  • Business
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Gaming
    • Movie
    • Music
    • Series
    Image credits - Joe Shlabotnik / Flickr

    Key winners at the 2021 Golden Globes

    Image credits - Gage Skidmore

    Chadwick Boseman Wins Best Actor at 2021 Golden Globes for Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom

    The film, a tale of an adolescent boy fighting human-eating demons, has amassed $313 million since opening on Oct. 16. © Koyoharu Gotoge/Shueisha, Aniplex, ufotable

    Japan anime movie ‘Demon Slayer’ lands in US cinemas

    Bengali Adhunik song Bela Hole Absan

    Bengali Adhunik song Bela Hole Absan

    Image credits - Steven Cordes / Unsplash

    Gotta catch ’em all: Pandemic sends prices soaring for Pokemon cards

    Image credits - Fixelgraphy / Unsplash

    Spotify to expand into more than 80 new markets including Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Maldives

    Image credits - AdamBMorgan / big-ashb

    Grammy-winning duo Daft Punk announces split after 28 years

    Image credits - LupEnd007 / rodrigoferrari

    Kim Kardashian files for divorce from Kanye West

    Nollywood meets Bollywood in love tale ‘Namaste Wahala’

    Nollywood meets Bollywood in love tale ‘Namaste Wahala’

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health
    • Science
    • Travel
    Iranaitivu residents protest against COVID-19 burials

    Iranaitivu residents protest against COVID-19 burials

    Image credits - Neven Krcmarek / Unsplash

    Maezawa wants you: Japan billionaire seeks ‘crew’ for moon trip

    Image credits - Mark Paton / Unsplash

    One in four people will have hearing problems by 2050: WHO

    Disciplined societies may have tackled COVID better, but there is a downside in all

    China, U.S. should lift COVID-19 travel bans if herd immunity reached, Chinese epidemiologist says

    Image credits - Slash Gear

    Nestle expands plant-based products with new vegan KitKat bar

    India-made COVID-19 vaccine in Ghana

    India-made COVID-19 vaccine in Ghana

    Image credits - Stefan Spassov / Unsplash

    Japan appoints ‘minister of loneliness’ to help people home alone

    Image credits - freestocks / Unsplash

    Singapore trials Smartphone app offering mini check-ups

    First human case of H5N8 bird flu reported in Russia. Image credits - CDC

    First human case of H5N8 bird flu reported in Russia

    Image credits - LupEnd007 / rodrigoferrari

    Kim Kardashian files for divorce from Kanye West

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
  • Tech
    Image credits - Benjamin Raffetseder / Unsplash

    China’s Xiaomi adds manufacturing muscle in India to boost phone production

    Image credits - freestocks / Unsplash

    Singapore trials Smartphone app offering mini check-ups

    Image credits - Fixelgraphy / Unsplash

    Spotify to expand into more than 80 new markets including Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Maldives

    Image credits - Nicole de Andrade

    Tech Tips: Signal lets users create groups with up to 1000 members, here is how to create one

    Whatsapp / Pic - India Today

    WhatsApp to switch off messages for all who reject new terms

    Image credits - Solen Feyissa / Unsplash

    Facebook news goes dark in Australia as content spat escalates

    Trending Tags

    • Sillicon Valley
    • Climate Change
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
    • Golden Globes
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Mr. Robot
  • Coronavirus
No Result
View All Result
NewsIn.Asia
No Result
View All Result
Home Business

Livemint says India’s official GDP data includes non-existing firms

Editor by Editor
May 10, 2019
in Business, India, Recommend
Reading Time: 4min read
2 0
Share on WhatsApp

By Pramit Bhattacharya/Livemint

New Delhi,  March 10: A key database introduced in India’s new gross domestic product (GDP) series has now been found to be full of holes, raising fresh questions over the controversial and contested GDP numbers in Asia’s third-largest economy.

A study conducted by the National Sample Survey Office (NSSO) in the 12 months ended June 2017 and released last week has found that as much as 38% of companies that are part of MCA-21 database of companies and are used in India’s GDP calculations could not be traced or were wrongly classified.

The results were so disappointing that two detailed reports based on the survey had to be junked. It is worth noting that these companies were deemed as “active companies” by the ministry of corporate affairs (MCA), which includes any company that has filed returns at least once in the past three years on its list of active firms.

Statisticians say the use of the untested database in India’s national accounts also raises troubling questions about the decline of the Central Statistics Office (CSO), which was once a globally renowned institution, and the reliability of India’s official statistics.

“This is a devastating blow for CSO,” said R. Nagaraj, a professor at the Indira Gandhi Institute of Development Research in Mumbai. “Some of us had repeatedly asked CSO officials to verify the MCA-21 numbers before using them in national accounts, but they finalized the new series without adequate scrutiny and debate.”

The key change in the new GDP series launched in 2015 was the use of MCA-21, which CSO sourced from MCA. Even at the time it was being introduced in the national accounts calculations, several economists had raised questions on this issue (see “The truth behind India’s new GDP numbers”, Mint, 2 April 2015). Nagaraj was among the first to raise red flags on this.

Critics argued that the database includes many fictitious or shell firms that exist only on paper. They also said the methodology used to plug in the MCA-21 numbers in the national accounts tends to lend an overestimation bias in the GDP numbers. They demanded the MCA-21 data be released to researchers and the public so that the unit-level data could be examined. Even those who thought the new GDP series represented a great methodological leap by CSO made the same demand.

So far, India’s national accounts statisticians at CSO have defended the use of the new database although they stopped short of making it public. But now, their own colleagues from NSSO have warned about the presence of a large number of ghost firms in the database.

NSSO got into the act while carrying out a survey on the service sector (74th round), supposed to be a first-of-its-kind survey on the service sector. The MCA-21 database was used as part of the sampling frame for the survey as it had addresses and other details of firms. Business registers in states that had such registers and data from the last economic census were the other parts of the sampling frame.

This survey strategy was approved by the National Statistical Commission (NSC) two years ago, and later even a tabulation plan for the two reports that were to be generated on the basis of this survey was approved by it.

The disappointing results from the field led NSC to suggest a short technical report instead of the two reports it had sanctioned earlier.

That NSSO report highlights the gravity of the problem. 16.4% of the firms listed in the MCA-21 frame either could not be traced or were found to be closed. Another 21.4% were found “out of coverage”, suggesting they were no longer operating as service sector firms though they had registered—and were being captured in national accounts—as such.

“The problem of non-response was severe in case of units chosen from MCA frame,” the report says. “About 45% of MCA units were found to be out-of-survey/casualty while EC/BR (economic census/business register) frame had about 18% of such cases.” The report shows that many of them are fake or shell firms, said Nagaraj. “They remain legally registered but without producing goods and services.”

P.C. Mohanan, former NSC member and former NSSO chief, said the MCA-21 database did not receive the scrutiny it should have. Mohanan, who resigned from NSC in December over the suppression of an NSSO jobs report, was at NSC when the 74th round results first came in.

“The CSO should have done some kind of critical scrutiny and validation before using the MCA-21 database in the new GDP series, either through quick surveys or by comparing with other databases, or consultations with accountants familiar with company filings,” said Mohanan. “That kind of critical examination was always done by CSO whenever they introduced new databases earlier, but I am not sure if MCA-21 data was examined in the same manner. This was all the more important because unlike other databases such as ASI or NSSO surveys used by CSO, this database is not publicly available.”

Nagaraj said the database should be made public, and that a statistical audit by independent experts was sorely needed.

The then chief statistician, T.C.A. Anant, under whose watch the new GDP series was prepared, declined to comment, saying he was a member of the Union Public Service Commission now, and would not like to speak to reporters. A spokesperson for the ministry of statistics and programme implementation did not comment on the implications for the GDP series.

 

SendShare5Tweet1ShareShare
Editor

Editor

Recommended Articles

  • All
  • Recommend
Iranaitivu residents protest against COVID-19 burials

Iranaitivu residents protest against COVID-19 burials

March 3, 2021
A conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952)

A conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952)

March 2, 2021
Lanka, India, Maldives set up Maritime Security Secretariat

Lanka, India, Maldives set up Maritime Security Secretariat

March 2, 2021
Imran Khan adds new dimensions to ties with Sri Lanka

Imran Khan adds new dimensions to ties with Sri Lanka

March 1, 2021
Nawam Perahera in Colombo was a colour fest, though with fewer elephants

Nawam Perahera in Colombo was a colour fest, though with fewer elephants

February 27, 2021
COVID body being brought for cremation in Sri Lanka

Sri Lanka finally allows burial of Covid-19 victims

February 25, 2021

Advertorial

  • All
  • Advertorial
Visual and Textual Analysis for Images with Reverse Search Tools

Visual and Textual Analysis for Images with Reverse Search Tools

January 3, 2021

Popular Now

  • UNHRC debate: A majority of countries spoke in favour of Sri Lanka

    UNHRC debate: A majority of countries spoke in favour of Sri Lanka

    70 shares
    Share 53 Tweet 7
  • Background to Lanka’s decision to lift ban on burying COVID dead

    32 shares
    Share 21 Tweet 5
  • India tells UNHRC devolution of power is critical for reconciliation in Sri Lanka

    47 shares
    Share 38 Tweet 4
  • Tokyo asks China to stop anal swab tests for COVID-19 on Japanese citizens

    21 shares
    Share 13 Tweet 3
  • Lanka takes three crucial decisions to garner Indian and Muslim support in UNHRC

    11 shares
    Share 4 Tweet 3
  • About Us
  • Advertisements
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact

© 2020 NewsIn.Asia - Lovingly maintained by DigitalArc.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Around South Asia
    • Afghanistan
    • Bangladesh
    • Bhutan
    • China
    • India
    • Maldives
    • Myanmar
    • Nepal
    • Pakistan
    • Sri Lanka
  • Around The World
  • Breaking News
  • Business
    • Exchange
  • Climate Change
  • Governance
    • Crime
    • Diplomacy
    • Defense
    • Human Rights
    • Politics
    • Strategic Affairs
  • Lifestyle
    • Books
    • Entertainment
      • Arts
      • Cinema
      • Gaming
      • Music
      • Movie
      • Series
      • TV
    • Health
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Travel
  • Culture
    • Ethnicity
    • Gender
  • Development news
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Environment
  • Coronavirus
  • History
  • National
  • Offbeat
    • Media
    • Music and arts across South Asia
  • Recommended
    • Headlines
    • Highlights
    • Top Picture
    • Top Story
  • Religion
  • Science
  • Sports
    • Football
    • Cricket
      • LPL
      • IPL
    • Tennis
    • Formula 1
    • NBA
  • Tech
    • Instagram
  • United Nations
  • Weather
  • World
    • Japan
    • Russia
    • United States

© 2020 NewsIn.Asia - Lovingly maintained by DigitalArc.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In