Demystifying Tipu Sultan in the 21st century

By P. K. Balachandran

Colombo, November 22 (Daily Express): Friday, November 20, was the 270^th birth anniversary of Tipu Sultan, South India’s greatest anti-British ruler and military leader who died fighting the British in Srirangapatnam (aka Seringapatam) near Mysore in Karnataka on May 4, 1799. If there is an aversion for the ‘Tiger of Mysore’ in India today, it is because of motivated and malicious propaganda by British chroniclers and historians, says his biographer Prof. Mohibbul Hasan in his book History of Tipu Sultan.

However, the saddest part is that, now, the dark portrayal of Tipu by the British is grist to the Bharatiya Janata Party’s (BJP) anti-Muslim mill. The Hindu right wing is determined to remove him from the national pantheon of freedom fighters.

This is seen in Karnataka. From 2016 till 2018, the secular Congress government in that South Indian State celebratedTipu Jayanthiwith a grand procession on November 10 every year. But the BJP, which saw Tipu as a ‘tyrannical, anti-Hindu ruler’ abandoned the observance in 2019 after it came to power. The Congress’ contention that Tipu was non-communal and development-oriented fell on deaf ears.

That Tipu was not communal and had been an administrative innovator was clearly brought out by Prof. Mohibbul Hasan, who had taught history in Calcutta and Jamia Millia Universities. He ought to be appreciated for turning his vast domain into the most prosperous Indian princely state in 18^thCentury, when chaos prevailed in much of India.

If Tipu is viewed by a section of Hindus in a negative light, it is because of British propaganda, Hasan insists. W. Kirkpatrick, in his 1811 publicationSelect Letters of Tippoo Sultan, describes Tipu as an “intolerant bigot and a furious fanatic” who indulged in forcible conversions, mass circumcisions, destruction of temples and confiscation of temple lands. Kirkpatric’s views were later echoed by M. Wilks (1864), and H. H. Dodwell in hisCambridge History of India (1929). According to Hasan, if the British chroniclers painted Tipu in dark colours, it was because he had refused to pay tribute; tried to set the Nizam of Hyderabad and the Marathas against them; and sought an alliance with their European rivals, the French.

Non-communal

That Tipu was non-communal is evident in the fact that a number of top officials in his government were Hindus. Purnaiya was theMir Asaf(in charge of Revenue and Finance). Krishna Rao was his Treasurer. Shamaiya Iyengar was Minister of Police and Postal Department. Subba Rao was his chiefPeshkar(Chief Secretary). Srinivas Rao and Appaji Ram were his close confidantes. His agents in the Moghul Court in Delhi were Mool Chand and Sujan Rai. The Faujdar of Coorg was Nagappayya, a Brahmin. The Asafs (revenue officers) at Coimbatore and Palghat were Brahmins. The chief of Tipu’s irregular cavalry was Hari Singh. Rama Rao and Sivaji, a Maratha, commanded his regular cavalry. Tipu sent one of his Hindu Generals, Sripat Rao, to quell the Nair rebellion in Malabar.

Helped Sringeri Math and temples

In 1916, the Mysore government’s Director of Archaeology, K. Narasimhachar, discovered a bunch of letters in the Sringeri Sankara Math (monastery), which showed that Tipu had greatly helped the monastery and its head Sringeri Sankaracharya.

In 1791, the monastery was raided and pillaged by a Maratha chieftain, Raghunath Rao Patwardan, and the Sankaracharya had asked Tipu for help to restore it. Deeply grieved, Tipu wrote back saying: “People who have sinned against such a holy place are sure to suffer the consequences of their misdeeds at no distant date” and asked his officials to send cash and grains so that the idol of Goddess Sarada could be consecrated. He also donated a palanquin to the Sankaracharya and requested him to pray for the prosperity of his domain.

Tipu had contributed to the Lakshmikanta Temple at Kalale in Nanjangudtaluk; the Narayanaswami Temple at Melkote; the Srikantheswara Temple at Nanjangud and to the Ranganathaswami Temple at Srirangapatnam all in Karnataka. The greenish shivalinga at the Nanjandeswara temple is known asPadshalingabecause it was donated by Tipu, the ‘ruler’.

According to aSanad, Tipu “ordered” the continuation of worship at the Tirupathi Venkatachalapathi Temple. Biographer Hasan wonders if Tipu would have allowed the Ranganatha, Narasimha and Gangadhareswara temples to function in the Srirangapatnam Fort if he was an Islamic bigot.

Tipu was also an ardent believer in astrology and consulted astrologers daily, first thing in the morning.

Forcible conversions

Tipu is widely accused of indulging in forcible conversions in Kerala and Coorg. But according to Hasan, Tipu told his French General, Cossigny, that he ordered the forcible conversion of Nairs and Coorgis because these communities had staged rebellions repeatedly. It was reported that 70,000 were converted in Coorg, but this could not be true because the total population of Coorg was not that much, Hasan points out. According to Punganuri Ramachandra Rao in his Memoirs of Hyder and Tippoo (1849) only 500 were converted in Coorg.

Hasan admits that Catholics in Kanara were converted forcibly, but this was because they had helped the British defeat Tipu at Mangalore. But Tipu never tried to convert loyal subjects.

Administrative innovations

Hasan says that Tipu gave Mysore a progressive administration. He points out that J. Mill in hisHistory of British India(1848), acknowledged that as a ruler, Tipu sustained an “advantageous comparison with the greatest princes of the East”. Tipu’s country was “the best cultivated and the most flourishing in India,” Mill adds.

Tipu rationalized the administrative system; got rid of private middlemen; encouraged local industries; sought French industrial technology and tried to send one of his sons to France for a modern education. He set up a rocket regiment in his army. After his defeat in 1799, the British discovered as many as 600 launchers, 700 serviceable rockets and 9,000 empty rockets at Tipu’s fort, some of which were shipped to Britain for replication. The Royal Artillery Museum in Woolwich in the UK houses some of them. Tipu was a promoter of international trade and had sent trade delegations to Afghanistan, Iran, Turkey and Myanmar.