• About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertisements
  • Contact
Sunday, December 8, 2019
No Result
View All Result
NewsIn.Asia
  • Top Story
  • Around South Asia
    • Afghanistan
    • Bangladesh
    • China
    • India
    • Maldives
    • Myanmar
    • Nepal
    • Pakistan
    • Sri Lanka
  • World
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Travel
  • Arts
  • Cinema
  • Music
  • Offbeat
  • Interviews
  • Top Story
  • Around South Asia
    • Afghanistan
    • Bangladesh
    • China
    • India
    • Maldives
    • Myanmar
    • Nepal
    • Pakistan
    • Sri Lanka
  • World
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Travel
  • Arts
  • Cinema
  • Music
  • Offbeat
  • Interviews
No Result
View All Result
NewsIn.Asia
No Result
View All Result
Home Human Rights

The Modi Juggernaut seems unstoppable

by Editor
November 24, 2019
in Human Rights, India, Politics, Top Story
0 0
0
The Modi Juggernaut seems unstoppable

People hold a cut-out of India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi as they celebrate after the government scrapped the special status of Kashmir, in Ahmedabad, India, August 5, 2019. REUTERS/Amit Dave - RC1D166F2FA0

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

By P.K.Balachandran/Daily Express

Fuelled by an unprecedented parliamentary majority, the Narendra Modi Juggernaut in India is rolling on achieving its principal political objectives.

It all began with the acquisition of power over Information Commissioners both at the Central and the State (provincial) level through an amendment of the Right to Information (RTI) Act of 2005.

The amendment took away the independence of the Information Commissioners at both the Central and the State levels by doing away with their fixed term of five years and fixed conditions of service including their status and salary. These matters will now be determined by the Central government from time to time. The States have lost their powers over the RTI set up in their respective dominions.

The second act of the government was to criminalize “Instant Triple Talaq”, a system of Muslim divorce by which a husband could divorce his wife by saying/emailing/messaging “talaq” three times in quick succession.

This form of divorce, albeit very rarely used, has now been criminalized with a jail term of three years. Even though Islamic marriage is a civil contract, it has been brought under criminal law. This is a disability which is restricted to the Muslims. In no other community is divorce criminalized.

The Triple Takaq law gives no opportunity for a retraction on the part of the husband. It makes alimony compulsory, but does not address the question as to how a jailed husband will pay alimony if he belongs to the working class, a daily wage laborer or a salaried job holder.

The government then amended the Central Motor Vehicles Act which took away the States’ powers. All rules and fines are laid down by the Central Act, taking away the powers of the Regional or State level Transport Offices. There is thus no room for variations to suit local economic conditions and the peoples’ varying ability to pay the exorbitant fines.

Lastly, and most recently, the Modi government has abolished Art 370 of the constitution under which India’s only Muslim-majority State of Jammu and Kashmir (J and K) enjoyed some autonomy (at least notionally) since India got independence in 1947.

A constitutionally-backed special status was given to J and K in order to persuade it to join the Hindu-majority India at the time of the partition of India into a Hindu-majority India and a Muslim-majority Pakistan. As per the Instrument of Accession, signed by the government of India and the ruler of J and K Maharajah Hari Singh, J and K surrendered only three subjects of administration, namely Defense, External Affairs, Communication and Currency to the government of India, keeping the rest for itself.

J and K’s autonomous status was entered in the Indian constitution as Art 370 and Art 35A. Under Art 35A, which is linked to Art 370, J and K could draw a distinction between “Permanent Residents” and immigrants and give some privileges to the permanent residents or indigenous people, not available to immigrants. Permanent residents enjoyed reservation in government jobs and seats in educational institutions. Outsiders could not buy immovable property or do businesses. But with Art 370 gone, Art 35A has also gone. The people of J and K are now deprived of their special rights. The floodgates have been opened to immigrants and businessmen and property buyers from outside J and K. The communal and ethnic ration could change over time.

Furthermore, J and K has lost its status as a “State” and is now merely a Union Territory with limited powers. It will be ruled by New Delhi by and large. This is the first case in India of a State being reduced to a Union Territory. The loss of Statehood adds to the grievances as J and K is the only State to lose its Statehood in the history of independent India. It is like rubbing salt into a wound.

The Modi regime says that these measures had been taken to end the anomaly of an Indian State enjoying a Special Status and also to fight terrorism and separatism.

But the fear, expressed by the Congress and other parties, is that the abolition of Art 370 (and Art 35A which stems from it) will only further alienate the Muslims of J and K ,many of whom are fighting for Azadi or freedom. Pakistan, which has been supporting the separatist movement in J and K, will find it easier to do so now than ever before.

The government’s actions could lead to similar actions vis-à-vis other Indian States. There are eleven other States in India which enjoy Special Rights of one kind or the other. Many of the North Eastern States have privileges for indigenous populations of the kind Art 35A gave to J and K. These could also be withdrawn at will. And that could lead to alienation and unrest in these areas especially because these States had once wanted to secede from India.

Temporary or Permanent?

The Modi government argues that Art 370 was a “temporary” and “transitional” measure. But according to Prof.Faizan Mustafa, an expert in constitutional law, it was temporary only because the matter of accession was to be finally decided by a referendum. But a referendum never took place and will probably never take place.

Just because an Article of the constitution was described as “temporary” it does not mean that it cannot not exist for an indefinite period, Prof .Mustafa argues. He points out that reservations for the Schedules Castes and tribal communities were described as temporary as was the use of English as an official language in addition to Hindi. But both temporary provisions have continued to exist with no one challenging them.

To extend a central law to Jammu and Kashmir on the subjects included in the Instrument of Accession, “consultation” or “concurrence” of the J and K government was enjoined. But Art 370 was abolished without the consulting the State. With the State Assembly dissolved, it was the Governor, who is representative of the Center, who gave the assent to the abolition.

The abolition of Art 370 is riddled with unconstitutionalities and unconstitutional assumptions, which are likely to be challenged in the Supreme Court.

 

Recommended

  • Recommend
India-built 98 houses handed over to plantation workers in Nuwara Eliya, Sri Lanka

India-built 98 houses handed over to plantation workers in Nuwara Eliya, Sri Lanka

9 months ago
Indian restaurant chain founder P.Rajagopal surrenders in murder case

Indian restaurant chain founder P.Rajagopal surrenders in murder case

5 months ago
Indian sari manufacturers exploit patriotic sentiments to market “military” saris

Indian sari manufacturers exploit patriotic sentiments to market “military” saris

9 months ago
Modi could fall short of parliamentary majority by 39 seats in May 2019 poll: survey

Modi could fall short of parliamentary majority by 39 seats in May 2019 poll: survey

11 months ago
India asked YouTube to take down some videos of Indian pilot captured in Pakistan

India asked YouTube to take down some videos of Indian pilot captured in Pakistan

9 months ago
Load More

Popular News

    About Us

    NewsIn.Asia is a South Asian website, operating from Colombo and accessed by readers worldwide. It offers its readers timely, indepth and comprehensive coverage of South Asian news, views and analyses.

    Follow US

    • Doubt s expressed over alleged detention of Swiss Embassy staffer probe continues - Colombo Dec 5 newsin asia Sri Lanka s Foreign Ministry yesterday said that following investigations conducted so far into the alleged detention of the Swiss Embassy employee they believed that there was very little truth in the allegation leveled by the so called victim and this may be misinformation to sling mud against the political leadership See more on newsin asia
    • Swiss court says LTTE is not a criminal organization acquitting 12 local Tamil supporters - 12 Swiss Tamils were charged with collecting money for the LTTE from 1999 to 2009 See more on newsin asia
    • Lanka govt alerts airport about possibility of Swiss embassy employee fleeing the country - Govt wants to interview the alleged victim of abduction but Swiss embassy would not allow it See more on newsin asia
    • 6 wickets 0 runs Nepal s Anjali Chand creates T20I history at South Asian Games - December 2 India Today Nepal bowler Anjali Chand rewrote record books on Monday as she played wrecker-in-chief in Nepal s rout of Maldives in Pokhara Anjali Chand registered bowling figures of 6 for 0 as Nepal bundled out Maldives for 16 runs The home team gunned down the total in just 0 5 overs Anjali Chand See more on newsin asia
    • Renegotiating Hambantota port s lease period - Renegotiation Hambantota port lease period is a complex politico-legal issue See more on newsin asia
    • Evidence of abduction presented by Swiss mission don t accord with facts says Lankan govt - The Swiss embassy caught on the wrong foot See more on newsin asia
    • Pakistan Foreign Minister to meet Lankan Prez PM and FM on Monday - Bid to match India s vigorous diplomacy after Gotabaya Rajapaksa s stunning election victory in the Lankan election See more on newsin asia
    • Gotabaya says 13 th Amendment is part of Lankan constitution but alternatives to police power to provinces will be considered - President Gotabaya said that he will be frank with New Delhi to avoid misunderstandings See more on newsin asia
    • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Advertisements
    • Contact

    © 2018-19 NewsIn.Asia - Lovingly Maintained by DigitalArc.

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Top Story
    • Around South Asia
      • Afghanistan
      • Bangladesh
      • China
      • India
      • Maldives
      • Myanmar
      • Nepal
      • Pakistan
      • Sri Lanka
    • World
    • Business
    • Sports
    • Travel
    • Arts
    • Cinema
    • Music
    • Offbeat
    • Interviews

    © 2018-19 NewsIn.Asia - Lovingly Maintained by DigitalArc.

    Login to your account below

    Forgotten Password? Sign Up

    Fill the forms bellow to register

    All fields are required. Log In

    Retrieve your password

    Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

    Log In