• Latest
  • Trending

Why India cannot be a Hindu Pakistan

August 14, 2016
Fuel. Image credits - Wassim Chouak / Unsplash

Ceylon Petroleum Corporation increases fuel prices

February 1, 2023
Sri Lanka

Sri Lanka makes top 10 in ‘Most Instagrammable Places in the World 2023’

February 1, 2023
Exchange Rate

Foreign Currency Official Exchange Rates from Central Bank of Sri Lanka

February 1, 2023
Bangladesh

Bangladesh secures loans of $4.7 billion from IMF

February 1, 2023
Maithripala Sirisena

Maithripala Sirisena to contest next Presidential election

February 1, 2023
Electricity

Power cut schedule for today in Sri Lanka: February 1st

February 1, 2023
Sri Lanka opposition leader says future government under him is not obliged to back IMF and other deals

Sri Lanka opposition leader says future government under him is not obliged to back IMF and other deals

February 1, 2023
Child. Image credits - Filip Mroz @mroz / Unsplash

Your child’s academic success may start with their screen time as infants

January 31, 2023
Chief pilot Ian Porter with wife Michelle, daughters Samantha and Sydney, who act as his co-pilots, and son Christopher.. Image credits - Samantha Porter

The family of five flying around the world in a tiny plane

January 31, 2023
Gautam Adani, Photo.Business Standard

Who is India’s Adani and why is his company tanking?

January 31, 2023
Brazen hypocrisy of the Lankan professional elite and the lost promise of a welfare state

Brazen hypocrisy of the Lankan professional elite and the lost promise of a welfare state

January 31, 2023
Tory peer accused of ‘racially charged’ attack on BBC Modi documentary

Tory peer accused of ‘racially charged’ attack on BBC Modi documentary

January 31, 2023
  • About Us
  • Advertisements
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
Thursday, February 2, 2023
No Result
View All Result
NewsIn.Asia
  • Home
  • Around South Asia
    • All
    • Afghanistan
    • Bangladesh
    • Bhutan
    • China
    • India
    • Maldives
    • Myanmar
    • Nepal
    • Pakistan
    • Sri Lanka
    Fuel. Image credits - Wassim Chouak / Unsplash

    Ceylon Petroleum Corporation increases fuel prices

    Sri Lanka

    Sri Lanka makes top 10 in ‘Most Instagrammable Places in the World 2023’

    Exchange Rate

    Foreign Currency Official Exchange Rates from Central Bank of Sri Lanka

    Bangladesh

    Bangladesh secures loans of $4.7 billion from IMF

    Maithripala Sirisena

    Maithripala Sirisena to contest next Presidential election

    Electricity

    Power cut schedule for today in Sri Lanka: February 1st

    Sri Lanka opposition leader says future government under him is not obliged to back IMF and other deals

    Sri Lanka opposition leader says future government under him is not obliged to back IMF and other deals

    Gautam Adani, Photo.Business Standard

    Who is India’s Adani and why is his company tanking?

    Brazen hypocrisy of the Lankan professional elite and the lost promise of a welfare state

    Brazen hypocrisy of the Lankan professional elite and the lost promise of a welfare state

  • World
    • All
    • Japan
    • Russia
    • United Kingdom
    • United States
    Sri Lanka

    Sri Lanka makes top 10 in ‘Most Instagrammable Places in the World 2023’

    Bangladesh

    Bangladesh secures loans of $4.7 billion from IMF

    Chief pilot Ian Porter with wife Michelle, daughters Samantha and Sydney, who act as his co-pilots, and son Christopher.. Image credits - Samantha Porter

    The family of five flying around the world in a tiny plane

    Tory peer accused of ‘racially charged’ attack on BBC Modi documentary

    Tory peer accused of ‘racially charged’ attack on BBC Modi documentary

    Robert Clive and the taking of India

    Robert Clive and the taking of India

    Gandhi’s influence on Sri Lanka’s non-violent Independence struggle

    Gandhi’s influence on Sri Lanka’s non-violent Independence struggle

    The world is tired Of United States’ wars

    The world is tired Of United States’ wars

    Eggs

    India to export 50 million eggs to Malaysia

    Vaping

    Researchers uncover new negative effects of vaping

  • Business
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Books
    • Gaming
    • Movie
    • Music
    • Series
    "Avatar: The Way of Water" has soared into the $2 billion club of top grossing movies worldwide.

    ‘Avatar: The Way of Water’ crosses $2 billion mark in worldwide box office

    Pathaan

    Posters of Shah Rukh Khan’s Pathaan torn down and burnt outside cinemas in India

    Oscars 2023

    Oscars 2023: ‘Everything Everywhere All At Once’ leads nominations

    Much-awaited Sri Lankan 3D animation movie “Gajaman” coming to theatres

    Much-awaited Sri Lankan 3D animation movie “Gajaman” coming to theatres

    Prince William and Prince Harry arrive at the Canadian National Vimy Memorial in Vimy, France on April 9, 2017.. Image credits - Jack Taylor/Getty Images/File

    Prince Harry’s ‘Spare’ creates world record, becomes fastest selling non-fiction book

    Cocaine Bear (Credit: Universal Pictures)

    20 of the best films to watch in 2023

    Avatar

    Avatar: The Way Of Water passes USD 1B at the global box office

    (Image credit: Alamy)

    The 20 best films of 2022

    Harry and Meghan

    ‘Harry & Meghan’ is Netflix’s most watched documentary debut in its first week

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health
    • Science
    • Travel
    Child. Image credits - Filip Mroz @mroz / Unsplash

    Your child’s academic success may start with their screen time as infants

    Chief pilot Ian Porter with wife Michelle, daughters Samantha and Sydney, who act as his co-pilots, and son Christopher.. Image credits - Samantha Porter

    The family of five flying around the world in a tiny plane

    Vaping

    Researchers uncover new negative effects of vaping

    Paris. Image credits - Alexander Kagan allewollenalex / Unsplash

    World’s ‘most powerful’ tourism city revealed

    Image credits - NASA nasa / Unsplash

    Earth’s inner core may have started spinning other way

    Global citizenship and residence advisory firm Henley & Partners has released its quarterly report on the world's most desirable passports. Click on to find out which passport offers the most access in 2023. Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

    The world’s most powerful passport for 2023 revealed

    Image credits - Tetiana Bykovets tetiana_bykovets / Unsplash

    New research reveals reason why chocolate tastes so good

    NASA’s Webb telescope

    Extraterrestrial wonders: Webb Telescope detects its 1st exoplanet

    Asafoetida plant. Photo via Adobe Stock.

    The most controversial ingredient in Indian food

    Best diet for 2023 is the science-backed Mediterranean style of eating

    Best diet for 2023 is the science-backed Mediterranean style of eating

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
  • Tech
    Child. Image credits - Filip Mroz @mroz / Unsplash

    Your child’s academic success may start with their screen time as infants

    Donald Trump

    Meta says it will restore Donald Trump’s Facebook and Instagram accounts

    WhatsApp

    5 great new features coming to WhatsApp in 2023

    Binance

    Binance is now authorised in seven EU Member States and fifteen jurisdictions worldwide

    Elon Musk

    Elon Musk breaks world record for largest loss of personal fortune in history

    Microsoft

    Microsoft in talks to invest $10 bln in ChatGPT owner – Semafor

    Trending Tags

    • Sillicon Valley
    • Climate Change
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
    • Golden Globes
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Mr. Robot
  • Coronavirus
  • Videos
  • Home
  • Around South Asia
    • All
    • Afghanistan
    • Bangladesh
    • Bhutan
    • China
    • India
    • Maldives
    • Myanmar
    • Nepal
    • Pakistan
    • Sri Lanka
    Fuel. Image credits - Wassim Chouak / Unsplash

    Ceylon Petroleum Corporation increases fuel prices

    Sri Lanka

    Sri Lanka makes top 10 in ‘Most Instagrammable Places in the World 2023’

    Exchange Rate

    Foreign Currency Official Exchange Rates from Central Bank of Sri Lanka

    Bangladesh

    Bangladesh secures loans of $4.7 billion from IMF

    Maithripala Sirisena

    Maithripala Sirisena to contest next Presidential election

    Electricity

    Power cut schedule for today in Sri Lanka: February 1st

    Sri Lanka opposition leader says future government under him is not obliged to back IMF and other deals

    Sri Lanka opposition leader says future government under him is not obliged to back IMF and other deals

    Gautam Adani, Photo.Business Standard

    Who is India’s Adani and why is his company tanking?

    Brazen hypocrisy of the Lankan professional elite and the lost promise of a welfare state

    Brazen hypocrisy of the Lankan professional elite and the lost promise of a welfare state

  • World
    • All
    • Japan
    • Russia
    • United Kingdom
    • United States
    Sri Lanka

    Sri Lanka makes top 10 in ‘Most Instagrammable Places in the World 2023’

    Bangladesh

    Bangladesh secures loans of $4.7 billion from IMF

    Chief pilot Ian Porter with wife Michelle, daughters Samantha and Sydney, who act as his co-pilots, and son Christopher.. Image credits - Samantha Porter

    The family of five flying around the world in a tiny plane

    Tory peer accused of ‘racially charged’ attack on BBC Modi documentary

    Tory peer accused of ‘racially charged’ attack on BBC Modi documentary

    Robert Clive and the taking of India

    Robert Clive and the taking of India

    Gandhi’s influence on Sri Lanka’s non-violent Independence struggle

    Gandhi’s influence on Sri Lanka’s non-violent Independence struggle

    The world is tired Of United States’ wars

    The world is tired Of United States’ wars

    Eggs

    India to export 50 million eggs to Malaysia

    Vaping

    Researchers uncover new negative effects of vaping

  • Business
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Books
    • Gaming
    • Movie
    • Music
    • Series
    "Avatar: The Way of Water" has soared into the $2 billion club of top grossing movies worldwide.

    ‘Avatar: The Way of Water’ crosses $2 billion mark in worldwide box office

    Pathaan

    Posters of Shah Rukh Khan’s Pathaan torn down and burnt outside cinemas in India

    Oscars 2023

    Oscars 2023: ‘Everything Everywhere All At Once’ leads nominations

    Much-awaited Sri Lankan 3D animation movie “Gajaman” coming to theatres

    Much-awaited Sri Lankan 3D animation movie “Gajaman” coming to theatres

    Prince William and Prince Harry arrive at the Canadian National Vimy Memorial in Vimy, France on April 9, 2017.. Image credits - Jack Taylor/Getty Images/File

    Prince Harry’s ‘Spare’ creates world record, becomes fastest selling non-fiction book

    Cocaine Bear (Credit: Universal Pictures)

    20 of the best films to watch in 2023

    Avatar

    Avatar: The Way Of Water passes USD 1B at the global box office

    (Image credit: Alamy)

    The 20 best films of 2022

    Harry and Meghan

    ‘Harry & Meghan’ is Netflix’s most watched documentary debut in its first week

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health
    • Science
    • Travel
    Child. Image credits - Filip Mroz @mroz / Unsplash

    Your child’s academic success may start with their screen time as infants

    Chief pilot Ian Porter with wife Michelle, daughters Samantha and Sydney, who act as his co-pilots, and son Christopher.. Image credits - Samantha Porter

    The family of five flying around the world in a tiny plane

    Vaping

    Researchers uncover new negative effects of vaping

    Paris. Image credits - Alexander Kagan allewollenalex / Unsplash

    World’s ‘most powerful’ tourism city revealed

    Image credits - NASA nasa / Unsplash

    Earth’s inner core may have started spinning other way

    Global citizenship and residence advisory firm Henley & Partners has released its quarterly report on the world's most desirable passports. Click on to find out which passport offers the most access in 2023. Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

    The world’s most powerful passport for 2023 revealed

    Image credits - Tetiana Bykovets tetiana_bykovets / Unsplash

    New research reveals reason why chocolate tastes so good

    NASA’s Webb telescope

    Extraterrestrial wonders: Webb Telescope detects its 1st exoplanet

    Asafoetida plant. Photo via Adobe Stock.

    The most controversial ingredient in Indian food

    Best diet for 2023 is the science-backed Mediterranean style of eating

    Best diet for 2023 is the science-backed Mediterranean style of eating

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
  • Tech
    Child. Image credits - Filip Mroz @mroz / Unsplash

    Your child’s academic success may start with their screen time as infants

    Donald Trump

    Meta says it will restore Donald Trump’s Facebook and Instagram accounts

    WhatsApp

    5 great new features coming to WhatsApp in 2023

    Binance

    Binance is now authorised in seven EU Member States and fifteen jurisdictions worldwide

    Elon Musk

    Elon Musk breaks world record for largest loss of personal fortune in history

    Microsoft

    Microsoft in talks to invest $10 bln in ChatGPT owner – Semafor

    Trending Tags

    • Sillicon Valley
    • Climate Change
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
    • Golden Globes
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Mr. Robot
  • Coronavirus
  • Videos
NewsIn.Asia
No Result
View All Result
Home Around South Asia India

Why India cannot be a Hindu Pakistan

Editor by Editor
August 14, 2016
in India
Reading Time: 4 mins read
2 0
A A

Mahatma Gandhi was opposed to the creation of Pakistan but once it was established, he wanted friendly relations with it.

Share on WhatsApp

Ramachandra Guha/The Hindustan Times

In the Europe of the 18th and 19th centuries, people of a particular territory were brought together (sometimes forcibly) to constitute a nation. Most often, the basis for unity was a common language and a common enemy. Thus, to be French meant you spoke French and hated the English. To be English meant that you spoke English and hated the French.

Sometimes, a dominant religion became a third key pillar of national identity. Hence Protestants were regarded as more authentically English than Catholics. In France, on the other hand, Catholics were privileged and Protestants persecuted. Likewise, to be a good Pole meant you spoke Polish, were Catholic, detested Jews (even or especially if these were born and raised in Poland), and disliked either Russia or Germany, depending on which was posing a greater threat to Poland’s national existence.

ADVERTISEMENT

In its conception Pakistan was a perfect European nation. Language and religion were both key to the constitution of Jinnah’s nation. And so was a common enemy. To be truly and properly Pakistani meant that you spoke Urdu, were a Muslim, and hated India.

Mahatma Gandhi, on the other hand, refused to define Indian-ness in terms of either religion or language. Although Hindus were a majority, India was not constituted as a Hindu country. Muslims and Christians and Sikhs and Parsis were given rights of equal citizenship. Although a plurality of Indians spoke Hindi, if one preferred to speak, write, or be taught in another language that was entirely acceptable too.

Gandhi knew that the nation could be brought together and held together only on the basis of pluralism and diversity. He was right. For it was the imposition of Urdu on East Pakistan that led to the creation of Bangladesh. It was the denial of equal status to Tamil and Tamils that led to a bloody civil war in Sri Lanka. Unlike its neighbours, India encouraged and promoted linguistic diversity, and was the luckier for it.

Remarkably, Gandhi refused even to demonize the nation which ruled India. He detested imperialism, yet recognized that individual officers and proconsuls were often honorable men. He thought the British had many virtues (tolerance, moderation and punctuality among them) that Indians would do well to adopt. He repeatedly said that once the British departed and India became free, the two countries would forge friendly relations (as they indeed have done).

V.D.Savarakar ,was an anti-British nationalist who became an anti-Muslim and anti-Pakistan nationalist and who was an accused in the Gandhi assassination case.
V.D.Savarakar ,was an anti-British nationalist who became an anti-Muslim and anti-Pakistan nationalist and who was an accused in the Gandhi assassination case.

This insistence on a nationalism that was positive rather than adversarial extended to Gandhi’s views on Pakistan. He opposed Pakistan’s invasion of Kashmir, but refused to let this lead him into a spirit of vengeance. He insisted that the Government of India transfer the money it owed to the Government of Pakistan. Had he not been murdered in January 1948, he would have continued his peace mission across the border, in West Punjab and in Sind.

Where Gandhi’s model of nationalism was innovative and original, other Indian thinkers and organizations were more derivative in their approach. Even before Jinnah’s Muslim League had pledged itself to a Muslim Pakistan, VD Savarkar and his Hindu Mahasabha had demanded a Hindu India. Since they had seen European nations consolidate themselves on the basis of a shared language, some Indian politicians wanted us to do likewise. Among the most fervent proponents of imposing Hindi on all of India were the conservative MS Golwalkar and the socialist Rammanohar Lohia. Finally, since many Pakistanis hated India and Indians, some ideologues wished us to return this hatred, preferably in an intensified form.

Since the nation was born, 69 years ago this week, Hindutva and Hindi ideologues have sought to unite citizens on the basis of a common religion, a common language, and a common enemy. Fortunately, this project has been resisted for as long. Secularists, pluralists, atheists, and plain old-fashioned democrats have come together to thwart the Hindutva agenda of fusing faith with state. Hindi chauvinists have been opposed with equal vigor, especially in South India.

And although their stoking of the conflict in Kashmir and the four wars they have fought against us have not endeared Pakistan to India, most Indians have not equated national pride with the hatred of Pakistan or Pakistanis.

The Republic of India has failed many of its citizens, by not providing them decent education and health care, or by not protecting them from violence and discrimination. On the other hand, its record of regular and freely contested multi-party elections is unparalleled for a country of its size and complexity. Its commitment to, and more or less successful fulfillment of linguistic pluralism is similarly unequalled.

Its record on religious pluralism is more mixed; even so, that in a neighborhood so dominated by Islamic fundamentalism we are not yet a ‘Hindu Rashtra’ must be reckoned a modest achievement.

The Republic of India is still a work in progress. It may yet forget or deny its original, plural and tolerant model of nationalism, and instead adopt the more aggressive, adversarial and homogenizing model of nationalism first invented in Europe and later taken further in countries such as Pakistan and Sri Lanka.

M.s.Golwalkar ,leader of the Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh (RSS) who asked for a Hindu India before Mohammad Ali Jinnah asked for a Muslim Pakistan
M.s.Golwalkar ,leader of the Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh (RSS) who asked for a Hindu India before Mohammad Ali Jinnah asked for a Muslim Pakistan

Indeed, with the BJP in power, the RSS in the ascendant, and the airwaves dominated by channels whose TRPs depend on stoking jingoism, there is an increasing tendency to submit ordinary Indians to a series of coercive loyalty tests.

This must be rejected. For to be a good or patriotic Indian one does not have to be a Hindu by birth, religious practice, or cultural affiliation. One does not need to know or speak Hindi, either. And one does not even have to hate Pakistan.

Historian Ramachandra Guha is the author of  India after Gandhi. 

 

Related Posts

Gautam Adani, Photo.Business Standard
Around South Asia

Who is India’s Adani and why is his company tanking?

January 31, 2023
Tory peer accused of ‘racially charged’ attack on BBC Modi documentary
Diplomacy

Tory peer accused of ‘racially charged’ attack on BBC Modi documentary

January 31, 2023
Robert Clive and the taking of India
India

Robert Clive and the taking of India

January 31, 2023
Gandhi’s influence on Sri Lanka’s non-violent Independence struggle
India

Gandhi’s influence on Sri Lanka’s non-violent Independence struggle

January 30, 2023
The Mughals gave India the concept of a “pleasure garden” 
Culture

The Mughals gave India the concept of a “pleasure garden” 

January 31, 2023
Jaishankar’s visit reset bilateral relations, says Sri Lankan envoy
Defense

Jaishankar’s visit reset bilateral relations, says Sri Lankan envoy

January 30, 2023
  • Electricity

    Power cut schedule for today in Sri Lanka: February 1st

    58378 shares
    Share 23369 Tweet 14587
  • Registration open for National Fuel Pass

    6625 shares
    Share 2687 Tweet 1641
  • Foreign Currency Official Exchange Rates from Central Bank of Sri Lanka

    1674 shares
    Share 676 Tweet 416
  • WATCH : Yohani’s first live performance in India

    789 shares
    Share 328 Tweet 192
  • Power interruption schedule released: Check your area power cut time

    747 shares
    Share 325 Tweet 176
  • About Us
  • Advertisements
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact

© 2022 All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Around South Asia
    • Afghanistan
    • Bangladesh
    • Bhutan
    • China
    • India
    • Maldives
    • Myanmar
    • Nepal
    • Pakistan
    • Sri Lanka
  • Around The World
  • Breaking News
  • Business
    • Exchange
  • Climate Change
  • Governance
    • Crime
    • Diplomacy
    • Defense
    • Human Rights
    • Politics
    • Strategic Affairs
  • Lifestyle
    • Books
    • Entertainment
      • Arts
      • Cinema
      • Gaming
      • Music
      • Movie
      • Series
      • TV
    • Health
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Travel
  • Culture
    • Ethnicity
    • Gender
  • Development news
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Environment
  • Coronavirus
  • History
  • National
  • Offbeat
    • Media
    • Music and arts across South Asia
  • Recommended
    • Headlines
    • Highlights
    • Top Picture
    • Top Story
  • Religion
  • Science
  • Sports
    • Football
    • Cricket
      • LPL
      • IPL
    • Tennis
    • Formula 1
    • NBA
  • Tech
    • Instagram
  • United Nations
  • Weather
  • World
    • Japan
    • Russia
    • United States
  • Videos

© 2022 All rights reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

eskisehir escort -

https://www.vudols.com/

- Sağlık Personeli - mersin escort - Antalya korsan taksi