• Latest
  • Trending

From human being to ‘human shield’: The story of a young Kashmiri, Farooq Dar

May 23, 2017
Lanka, India, Maldives set up Maritime Security Secretariat

Lanka, India, Maldives set up Maritime Security Secretariat

March 2, 2021
Image credits - Joe Shlabotnik / Flickr

Key winners at the 2021 Golden Globes

March 1, 2021
India displays its air power and manufacturing capabilities in Lankan air show

India displays its air power and manufacturing capabilities in Lankan air show

March 1, 2021
Image credits - Torstensimon

Fauci urges Americans to get any of the three COVID-19 vaccines available

March 1, 2021
Image credits - Gage Skidmore

Chadwick Boseman Wins Best Actor at 2021 Golden Globes for Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom

March 1, 2021
Imran Khan adds new dimensions to ties with Sri Lanka

Imran Khan adds new dimensions to ties with Sri Lanka

March 1, 2021
Image credits - David Brooke Martin / Unsplash

Indian rooster kills owner during cockfight

March 1, 2021
Image credits - AJ Colores / Unsplash

At least 18 killed in Myanmar on bloodiest day of protests against coup

March 1, 2021
Image credits - Hakan Nural / Unsplash

AstraZeneca has sold its stake in Moderna for more than $1 billion: The Times

March 1, 2021
India-made Indian Air Force planes in Lankan Air Forces’ 70 th. Anniversary celebrations

India-made Indian Air Force planes in Lankan Air Forces’ 70 th. Anniversary celebrations

February 28, 2021
Nawam Perahera in Colombo was a colour fest, though with fewer elephants

Nawam Perahera in Colombo was a colour fest, though with fewer elephants

February 27, 2021
Image credits - Joshua Sukoff / Unsplash

Saudi crown prince approved operation to capture or kill Khashoggi: US intelligence report

February 27, 2021
  • About Us
  • Advertisements
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
Tuesday, March 2, 2021
  • Login
  • Register
No Result
View All Result
NewsIn.Asia
  • Home
  • Around South Asia
    • All
    • Afghanistan
    • Bangladesh
    • Bhutan
    • China
    • India
    • Maldives
    • Myanmar
    • Nepal
    • Pakistan
    • Sri Lanka
    Lanka, India, Maldives set up Maritime Security Secretariat

    Lanka, India, Maldives set up Maritime Security Secretariat

    India displays its air power and manufacturing capabilities in Lankan air show

    India displays its air power and manufacturing capabilities in Lankan air show

    Imran Khan adds new dimensions to ties with Sri Lanka

    Imran Khan adds new dimensions to ties with Sri Lanka

    Image credits - David Brooke Martin / Unsplash

    Indian rooster kills owner during cockfight

    Image credits - AJ Colores / Unsplash

    At least 18 killed in Myanmar on bloodiest day of protests against coup

    India-made Indian Air Force planes in Lankan Air Forces’ 70 th. Anniversary celebrations

    India-made Indian Air Force planes in Lankan Air Forces’ 70 th. Anniversary celebrations

    Nawam Perahera in Colombo was a colour fest, though with fewer elephants

    Nawam Perahera in Colombo was a colour fest, though with fewer elephants

    Image credits - Mint

    Low gold prices spark flurry of activity in India

    Image credits - ICC (Twitter)

    India’s double World Cup winner Yusuf Pathan retires

  • World
    • All
    • Japan
    • Russia
    • United States
    Image credits - Torstensimon

    Fauci urges Americans to get any of the three COVID-19 vaccines available

    Image credits - Joshua Sukoff / Unsplash

    Saudi crown prince approved operation to capture or kill Khashoggi: US intelligence report

    Image credits - Joshua Oluwagbemiga / Unsplash

    Gunmen take 317 schoolgirls in Nigeria’s latest mass abduction

    Image credits - Timothy Newman / Unsplash

    Biden launched airstrikes against Iran-backed militias in Syria to “send a message”

    Image credits - Slash Gear

    Nestle expands plant-based products with new vegan KitKat bar

    Image credits - Joshua Sukoff / Unsplash

    Biden discussed renewed diplomatic efforts to end the war in Yemen with Saudi King Salman

    Image credits - Daniel Schludi / Unsplash

    Brazil to buy 20 million COVID-19 vaccines from India’s Bharat Biotech

    Image credits - Nathan Dumlao / Unsplash

    Cocaine ‘worth billions’ seized in record Germany and Belgium haul

    Image credits - Hakan Nural / Unsplash

    Boost for COVID-19 battle, Pfizer vaccine found 94% effective in real world

  • Business
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Gaming
    • Movie
    • Music
    • Series
    Image credits - Joe Shlabotnik / Flickr

    Key winners at the 2021 Golden Globes

    Image credits - Gage Skidmore

    Chadwick Boseman Wins Best Actor at 2021 Golden Globes for Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom

    The film, a tale of an adolescent boy fighting human-eating demons, has amassed $313 million since opening on Oct. 16. © Koyoharu Gotoge/Shueisha, Aniplex, ufotable

    Japan anime movie ‘Demon Slayer’ lands in US cinemas

    Bengali Adhunik song Bela Hole Absan

    Bengali Adhunik song Bela Hole Absan

    Image credits - Steven Cordes / Unsplash

    Gotta catch ’em all: Pandemic sends prices soaring for Pokemon cards

    Image credits - Fixelgraphy / Unsplash

    Spotify to expand into more than 80 new markets including Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Maldives

    Image credits - AdamBMorgan / big-ashb

    Grammy-winning duo Daft Punk announces split after 28 years

    Image credits - LupEnd007 / rodrigoferrari

    Kim Kardashian files for divorce from Kanye West

    Nollywood meets Bollywood in love tale ‘Namaste Wahala’

    Nollywood meets Bollywood in love tale ‘Namaste Wahala’

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health
    • Science
    • Travel
    Image credits - Slash Gear

    Nestle expands plant-based products with new vegan KitKat bar

    India-made COVID-19 vaccine in Ghana

    India-made COVID-19 vaccine in Ghana

    Image credits - Stefan Spassov / Unsplash

    Japan appoints ‘minister of loneliness’ to help people home alone

    Image credits - freestocks / Unsplash

    Singapore trials Smartphone app offering mini check-ups

    First human case of H5N8 bird flu reported in Russia. Image credits - CDC

    First human case of H5N8 bird flu reported in Russia

    Image credits - LupEnd007 / rodrigoferrari

    Kim Kardashian files for divorce from Kanye West

    “What you say is not as important as the bookcase behind you”

    “What you say is not as important as the bookcase behind you”

    Swati Mohan spearheaded the attitude control and landing system of the Perseverance rover. (Image: Nasa)

    Swati Mohan, Indian-American scientist who led charge to land Nasa rover on Mars, was inspired by Star Trek as a kid

    Image credits - Luca Rüegg / Unsplash

    NASA’s astrobiology rover Perseverance makes historic Mars landing

    Image credits - Arlington Research / Unsplash

    Pandemic to widen skill gaps as workplaces change, McKinsey says

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
  • Tech
    Image credits - Benjamin Raffetseder / Unsplash

    China’s Xiaomi adds manufacturing muscle in India to boost phone production

    Image credits - freestocks / Unsplash

    Singapore trials Smartphone app offering mini check-ups

    Image credits - Fixelgraphy / Unsplash

    Spotify to expand into more than 80 new markets including Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Maldives

    Image credits - Nicole de Andrade

    Tech Tips: Signal lets users create groups with up to 1000 members, here is how to create one

    Whatsapp / Pic - India Today

    WhatsApp to switch off messages for all who reject new terms

    Image credits - Solen Feyissa / Unsplash

    Facebook news goes dark in Australia as content spat escalates

    Trending Tags

    • Sillicon Valley
    • Climate Change
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
    • Golden Globes
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Mr. Robot
  • Coronavirus
  • Home
  • Around South Asia
    • All
    • Afghanistan
    • Bangladesh
    • Bhutan
    • China
    • India
    • Maldives
    • Myanmar
    • Nepal
    • Pakistan
    • Sri Lanka
    Lanka, India, Maldives set up Maritime Security Secretariat

    Lanka, India, Maldives set up Maritime Security Secretariat

    India displays its air power and manufacturing capabilities in Lankan air show

    India displays its air power and manufacturing capabilities in Lankan air show

    Imran Khan adds new dimensions to ties with Sri Lanka

    Imran Khan adds new dimensions to ties with Sri Lanka

    Image credits - David Brooke Martin / Unsplash

    Indian rooster kills owner during cockfight

    Image credits - AJ Colores / Unsplash

    At least 18 killed in Myanmar on bloodiest day of protests against coup

    India-made Indian Air Force planes in Lankan Air Forces’ 70 th. Anniversary celebrations

    India-made Indian Air Force planes in Lankan Air Forces’ 70 th. Anniversary celebrations

    Nawam Perahera in Colombo was a colour fest, though with fewer elephants

    Nawam Perahera in Colombo was a colour fest, though with fewer elephants

    Image credits - Mint

    Low gold prices spark flurry of activity in India

    Image credits - ICC (Twitter)

    India’s double World Cup winner Yusuf Pathan retires

  • World
    • All
    • Japan
    • Russia
    • United States
    Image credits - Torstensimon

    Fauci urges Americans to get any of the three COVID-19 vaccines available

    Image credits - Joshua Sukoff / Unsplash

    Saudi crown prince approved operation to capture or kill Khashoggi: US intelligence report

    Image credits - Joshua Oluwagbemiga / Unsplash

    Gunmen take 317 schoolgirls in Nigeria’s latest mass abduction

    Image credits - Timothy Newman / Unsplash

    Biden launched airstrikes against Iran-backed militias in Syria to “send a message”

    Image credits - Slash Gear

    Nestle expands plant-based products with new vegan KitKat bar

    Image credits - Joshua Sukoff / Unsplash

    Biden discussed renewed diplomatic efforts to end the war in Yemen with Saudi King Salman

    Image credits - Daniel Schludi / Unsplash

    Brazil to buy 20 million COVID-19 vaccines from India’s Bharat Biotech

    Image credits - Nathan Dumlao / Unsplash

    Cocaine ‘worth billions’ seized in record Germany and Belgium haul

    Image credits - Hakan Nural / Unsplash

    Boost for COVID-19 battle, Pfizer vaccine found 94% effective in real world

  • Business
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Gaming
    • Movie
    • Music
    • Series
    Image credits - Joe Shlabotnik / Flickr

    Key winners at the 2021 Golden Globes

    Image credits - Gage Skidmore

    Chadwick Boseman Wins Best Actor at 2021 Golden Globes for Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom

    The film, a tale of an adolescent boy fighting human-eating demons, has amassed $313 million since opening on Oct. 16. © Koyoharu Gotoge/Shueisha, Aniplex, ufotable

    Japan anime movie ‘Demon Slayer’ lands in US cinemas

    Bengali Adhunik song Bela Hole Absan

    Bengali Adhunik song Bela Hole Absan

    Image credits - Steven Cordes / Unsplash

    Gotta catch ’em all: Pandemic sends prices soaring for Pokemon cards

    Image credits - Fixelgraphy / Unsplash

    Spotify to expand into more than 80 new markets including Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Maldives

    Image credits - AdamBMorgan / big-ashb

    Grammy-winning duo Daft Punk announces split after 28 years

    Image credits - LupEnd007 / rodrigoferrari

    Kim Kardashian files for divorce from Kanye West

    Nollywood meets Bollywood in love tale ‘Namaste Wahala’

    Nollywood meets Bollywood in love tale ‘Namaste Wahala’

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health
    • Science
    • Travel
    Image credits - Slash Gear

    Nestle expands plant-based products with new vegan KitKat bar

    India-made COVID-19 vaccine in Ghana

    India-made COVID-19 vaccine in Ghana

    Image credits - Stefan Spassov / Unsplash

    Japan appoints ‘minister of loneliness’ to help people home alone

    Image credits - freestocks / Unsplash

    Singapore trials Smartphone app offering mini check-ups

    First human case of H5N8 bird flu reported in Russia. Image credits - CDC

    First human case of H5N8 bird flu reported in Russia

    Image credits - LupEnd007 / rodrigoferrari

    Kim Kardashian files for divorce from Kanye West

    “What you say is not as important as the bookcase behind you”

    “What you say is not as important as the bookcase behind you”

    Swati Mohan spearheaded the attitude control and landing system of the Perseverance rover. (Image: Nasa)

    Swati Mohan, Indian-American scientist who led charge to land Nasa rover on Mars, was inspired by Star Trek as a kid

    Image credits - Luca Rüegg / Unsplash

    NASA’s astrobiology rover Perseverance makes historic Mars landing

    Image credits - Arlington Research / Unsplash

    Pandemic to widen skill gaps as workplaces change, McKinsey says

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
  • Tech
    Image credits - Benjamin Raffetseder / Unsplash

    China’s Xiaomi adds manufacturing muscle in India to boost phone production

    Image credits - freestocks / Unsplash

    Singapore trials Smartphone app offering mini check-ups

    Image credits - Fixelgraphy / Unsplash

    Spotify to expand into more than 80 new markets including Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Maldives

    Image credits - Nicole de Andrade

    Tech Tips: Signal lets users create groups with up to 1000 members, here is how to create one

    Whatsapp / Pic - India Today

    WhatsApp to switch off messages for all who reject new terms

    Image credits - Solen Feyissa / Unsplash

    Facebook news goes dark in Australia as content spat escalates

    Trending Tags

    • Sillicon Valley
    • Climate Change
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
    • Golden Globes
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Mr. Robot
  • Coronavirus
No Result
View All Result
NewsIn.Asia
No Result
View All Result
Home Around South Asia

From human being to ‘human shield’: The story of a young Kashmiri, Farooq Dar

Editor by Editor
May 23, 2017
in Around South Asia, India, Pakistan, Top Story
Reading Time: 5min read
1 0
Share on WhatsApp

By Shiv Visvanathan/Scroll In

Sometimes history and especially the history of violence has a way of teaching us lessons by telling the story from different angles. The classic narrative often cited in this context is Akira Kurosawa’s classic movie Rashomon where a murder is seen from three perspectives. The emphasis here is not to create a picture of relativism but a thick description of the event and the responses to it. The effort is to show how the production and consumption of the event are knitted together. Guilt or innocence can be part of a chain of being, implicating more than one person.

The recent controversy surrounding the use of a “human shield” by an army officer seems to be of such a complexity. As with other such events nowadays, it all started on Twitter, when former Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Omar Abdullah tweeted a video of a young man tied to the bonnet of an army jeep.

Abdullah’s response at first seemed to be about comparative consternation. A few days earlier there was a video of armed Central Police Reserve Force personnel being heckled and harassed by Kashmiri “ruffians”. This video had gone viral producing a tremendous wave of sympathy for the security forces and, what was seen as, their exemplary restraint.

To muddy the waters, some claimed, Abdullah had unleashed the video of the man on the bonnet, asking querulously why this video would not generate the same level of anger as the CRPF video.

There is something adolescent about Omar Abdullah. He looks like someone who has not forgiven the world for voting him out of power. Secondly, his consternation strikes a comparative note, an Orwellian hint that some violences should be more equal than others. Thirdly, his language is not clear. We are not sure whether he is conveying pique or injustice. One does not know whether he would have behaved the same way if he was in power. The stones pelting trend, after all, arose in his time and has acquired epidemic proportions.

The event itself has to be located within a context not just of the army’s brutalisation of itself and Kashmiri society but the immediate context of the election. The latest bye-elections in Kashmir were an embarrassment for India. The turnout was pathetic with Farooq Abdullah being elected on a 7% turnout from Sri Nagar. The general propaganda pictures about high voter turnout that India preened about were not available this time. Electoral democracy seems to have given up on Kashmir.

The more immediate context was the situation of a Rashtriya Rifles officer who, it was claimed, had to provide protection, in fact, rescue a polling team from a stone pelting mob. Official reports cited by The Economic Timesclaimed that the government has decided to stand by the army officer:

Army probe into the April 9 incident which concluded that the commanding officer took the decision reluctantly and as the last resort after he realised that his unit had to pass through streets crowded with a mob of stone-pelters who had also taken positions on surrounding rooftops.

Kashmiri youth stone Indian policeman

The trapped personnel included about a dozen local J&K employees, about 9-10 ITBP jawans, a couple of constables from J&K police and a bus driver.

The officer was lauded for his “quick thinking” which had led him to employ a ruse of tying a citizen to a bonnet and using him as a human shield. General GD Bakshi, a retired officer and regular presence on TV news channels, praised the officer for his “out of the Box thinking” which had “saved lives on both sides”, adding that the standard military solution was to shoot the pelters dead. Bakshi’s comments get more interesting. He slighted “the human rights tamasha” in Kashmir which, apparently, put the army at a disadvantage and added: “The Israelis do it routinely”.

Success seems to provide its own flavor and Israeli pragmatism seems to have a particular appeal for India. We project ourselves as twin countries caught in the same terrorist imbroglio. Bakshi’s comments are an example of an officer claiming that the ends justify the means, that a consequentialist ethics is all that matters. There is little or no reference to the fact that the Geneva convention bans the use of “human shields”.

In all this controversy, the experience of the victim hardly seems to matter. He is almost incidental to history, a piece of accident who happened to be there.

Other available accounts not readily available in mainstream media outlets, provide a different story. Here, the man on the bonnet of the jeep gets a name and a profession. He is Farooq Dar, a shawl weaver, resident of Chil village in Beerwah sub-district in in Kashmir’s Budgam district. In this account, he was was paraded around a dozen villagers.

Far from being a stone pelter, the irony was that Dar said he had gone out that day to vote and was riding his bike to attend a condolence meeting at his brother-in-law’s house in Gampora village when he was stopped by the forces in a village where some women were protesting against the elections. Being a well behaved citizen, evidently, does not cut ice in a community of stone pelters. Dar claimed he was beaten and paraded in an almost unconscious state in a dozen or so villages. He emphasised he was not a stone pelter. He said he would not complain as he was convinced no one would listen to a poor person. The dignity of an anonymous citizen hardly seems to matter as the forces of history enact their bigger egos.

Kashmiri women hide their faces as an Indian soldier passes by

Meanwhile, the country’s highest judicial officer, Attorney General Mukul Rohtagi, has spoken. Why was there so much noise about it, he wondered. “If it has to be done again, it should be done again,” he said in an interview. “We are 100 percent backing the Army and the major.”

The army, on its part, promised its ritual of enquiry. The army chief General Rawat had earlier warned that “over ground supporters” would be treated like “armed terrorists” if they hampered military operations.

The question one has to ask is whether legitimacy is only a cover, a screen or is it a lived-out ontology of values.

It is almost as if each professional group – whether it is party or media or army – is taking strategy while the wider issues of ethics and democracy seem second hand. In fact, it echoes the recent statement of Narendra Modi asking Kashmiri youth to opt between tourism and terrorism. There is a facileness here which again reveals an alienation, a distance from the ground. No wonder The Indian Expresseditorial shrugged Modi’s option off as “a blithe binary”.

As the video war proceeds, creating images of competitive violence, one can virtually sense it has a higher turnout than electoral politics. One has to ask whether there is an abandonment of grass roots politics as tweets and Facebook posts pretend to substitute for constituency battles.

Shiv Visvanathan ,the author of the article is a sociologist and Professor at the  Jindal Global Law School in Delhi  

I must admit that the text of the story is fragmented. Each provides a different coating of morality. Yet, I think the context is important. To think that each one of these incidents is separate and discontinuous refuses to understand that Kashmir has been at war with itself for close to seven decades now. The state of internal emergency has brutalised people, left politics hopeless and ethics empty. The Kashmiri society is caught in an amoral vortex where violence and brutality is read as normal.

Some may admire Major Gogoi’s quick thinking but the event is a deeper one. Even if one believes the army version, at one level, the Major’s act was a bit of triage – sacrificing a Kashmiri to save a bunch of officials. The moral luck was that the Dar came out of it alive, or the army might be putting Gogoi on the dock.

In fact, reading it all one senses that there is no real value for human life. Worse, there is no place for ethics in a world that talks strategy, efficiency, cost-benefit. The sadness of Kashmir politics from Abdullahs to the army is that it has created a democracy as an empty forum without values. The Vietnamisation of Kashmir is proceeding blithely as officials point fingers at each other. It is the death of ethics that is the scandal of Kashmir.

(The featured image at the top shows Farooq Dar an innocent young Kashmiri being used as a human shield to protect Indian troops against stone pelting Kashmiri youth) 

SendShare3TweetShareShare
Editor

Editor

Recommended Articles

  • All
  • Recommend
Lanka, India, Maldives set up Maritime Security Secretariat

Lanka, India, Maldives set up Maritime Security Secretariat

March 2, 2021
Imran Khan adds new dimensions to ties with Sri Lanka

Imran Khan adds new dimensions to ties with Sri Lanka

March 1, 2021
Nawam Perahera in Colombo was a colour fest, though with fewer elephants

Nawam Perahera in Colombo was a colour fest, though with fewer elephants

February 27, 2021
COVID body being brought for cremation in Sri Lanka

Sri Lanka finally allows burial of Covid-19 victims

February 25, 2021
Lanka-Pakistan ties to acquire a new look following Imran Khan’s visit

Lanka-Pakistan ties to acquire a new look following Imran Khan’s visit

February 25, 2021
Contribution of T.B.Jayah to Sri Lanka-Pakistan relations

Contribution of T.B.Jayah to Sri Lanka-Pakistan relations

February 23, 2021

Advertorial

  • All
  • Advertorial
Visual and Textual Analysis for Images with Reverse Search Tools

Visual and Textual Analysis for Images with Reverse Search Tools

January 3, 2021

Popular Now

  • UNHRC debate: A majority of countries spoke in favour of Sri Lanka

    UNHRC debate: A majority of countries spoke in favour of Sri Lanka

    67 shares
    Share 50 Tweet 7
  • Background to Lanka’s decision to lift ban on burying COVID dead

    32 shares
    Share 21 Tweet 5
  • India tells UNHRC devolution of power is critical for reconciliation in Sri Lanka

    44 shares
    Share 35 Tweet 4
  • Spotify to expand into more than 80 new markets including Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Maldives

    12 shares
    Share 5 Tweet 3
  • Vaccines roll out to public; six centres in Colombo

    12 shares
    Share 5 Tweet 3
  • About Us
  • Advertisements
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact

© 2020 NewsIn.Asia - Lovingly maintained by DigitalArc.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Around South Asia
    • Afghanistan
    • Bangladesh
    • Bhutan
    • China
    • India
    • Maldives
    • Myanmar
    • Nepal
    • Pakistan
    • Sri Lanka
  • Around The World
  • Breaking News
  • Business
    • Exchange
  • Climate Change
  • Governance
    • Crime
    • Diplomacy
    • Defense
    • Human Rights
    • Politics
    • Strategic Affairs
  • Lifestyle
    • Books
    • Entertainment
      • Arts
      • Cinema
      • Gaming
      • Music
      • Movie
      • Series
      • TV
    • Health
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Travel
  • Culture
    • Ethnicity
    • Gender
  • Development news
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Environment
  • Coronavirus
  • History
  • National
  • Offbeat
    • Media
    • Music and arts across South Asia
  • Recommended
    • Headlines
    • Highlights
    • Top Picture
    • Top Story
  • Religion
  • Science
  • Sports
    • Football
    • Cricket
      • LPL
      • IPL
    • Tennis
    • Formula 1
    • NBA
  • Tech
    • Instagram
  • United Nations
  • Weather
  • World
    • Japan
    • Russia
    • United States

© 2020 NewsIn.Asia - Lovingly maintained by DigitalArc.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In