Mumbai, December 13 (IndiaSpend): The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) lost 180 seats that it won in 2013, and the Congress gained 162 across three state assemblies–Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh (MP) and Chhattisgarh–as results were declared on December 11, 2018, according to an IndiaSpend analysis of electoral data.
In 2013, the BJP won 377 seats and the Congress 118 in these three states. The BJP had no seats in Mizoram in 2013, and this is the first state election for Telangana, which was created in 2014.
This means the BJP lost 48% of the seats it won in 2013, and the Congress gained 137%.
The difference in vote share between the two parties in Rajasthan and MP, both heartland Hindi-speaking states, was much closer, as we will explain; Congress vote shares in Rajasthan, MP and Chhattisgarh rose by 6, 5, and 3 percentage points since 2013.
Mizoram and Telangana were won by regional parties, the Mizo National Front and the Telangana Rashtra Samithi (TRS), respectively. While the Congress won Chhattisgarh with 68 of 90 seats (from 39 in 2013) and Rajasthan by winning 99 of 199 (from 21 in 2013), MP went to the wire with the Congress on 114 (from 58 in 2013) and the BJP on 109 (from 165 in 2013).
Some highlights of our analysis :
- The Congress was 0.1 percentage point behind the BJP in MP. In Rajasthan, it led by 0.5 percentage point.
- In Rajasthan, MP and Chhattisgarh, where more than 70% of the population lives in rural areas, farm distress appears to have played a significant role but not in Telangana, which is 61% rural and exhibits similar distress, as we reported on December 6, 2018.
- In Chhattisgarh, MP and Rajasthan, where 43%, 36%, and 30%, respectively, of seats are reserved for scheduled tribes and scheduled castes, except for Rajasthan, the BJP recorded its worst performance in a decade, while the Congress recorded its best.
Wafer thin vote-share margins in MP, Rajasthan
A strong wave of anti-incumbency swept through MP and Chhattisgarh–states where the BJP had been in power for 15 years since 2003–and Rajasthan, where no party has stayed in power for more than one term.
In MP, the vote shares of the BJP and the Congress were 41% and 40.9%, respectively. In 2013, the comparable vote shares were 45% and 36%.
In Rajasthan, the BJP and Congress vote shares were 38.8% and 39.3%, respectively. In 2013, the BJP vote share was 45% and the Congress 33%.
In Chhattisgarh, the BJP and Congress recorded vote shares of 33% and 43% respectively. In 2013, this was 41% for the BJP and 40% for the Congress.
Farm distress, it appears, played a key role in the BJP’s slide
On November 29, 2018, over 100,000 farmers from across India marched to Delhi to demand a special session of parliament to address India’s farming crisis. Nearly 80% or 20.4 million people in Chhattisgarh, 66% or 69 million in Rajasthan and 55% or 73 million in MP–the Indian average is 47%–are engaged in agriculture, indicating that farm distress may have played a significant role in electoral outcomes.
Madhya Pradesh: Despite a 10.9% annual agricultural growth rate over eight years to 2015 (India’s highest), the state witnessed farmer agitations, IndiaSpend reported on November 30, 2018. As many as 1,321 farmers committed suicide in MP in 2016, the highest since 2013, according to government data. While farm suicides dropped 10% nationwide, MP witnessed a 21% increase two years to 2016.
Of 230 seats polled for the MP assembly, the Congress won 114 seats, of which 81 seats were previously held by BJP.
Chhattisgarh: In a state considered to be India’s rice bowl, 1,344 farmers–519 a year or, more than one per day–committed suicide in Chhattisgarh over 30 months to October 30, 2017, theHindu Business Line reported on December 21, 2017.
The Congress had won 68 seats, of which 38 seats were previously held by the BJP, according to the latest election results.
Rajasthan: As in MP, farmers in Rajasthan also complained about not being able to meet costs, although the government increased the price at which it bought the kharif (monsoon) and rabi (winter) harvests.
Of 199 seats in the Rajasthan assembly, the Congress had won 99 seats. Of this, 74 seats were previously held by the BJP.
Telangana: In the four-and-a-half years since it won statehood, Telangana reported acute farm distress, with 2,190 farmers committing suicide–more than one every day–according to data from the state government’s police department, IndiaSpend reported on December 6, 2018.
Over 89% of rural agrarian households in Telangana are in debt–the Indian average is 52%–the second highest proportion in India after Andhra Pradesh, according to the Telangana Social Development Report published by the state government.
Yet, the TRS won 88 of 119 seats–with a 46.9% vote share–surpassing the 60 required for a majority. Chief minister K. Chandrashekar Rao, who has been in power since the state’s formation in 2014, will return for a second term.
Over a third of BJP’s losses recorded in Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes seats
Across Chhattisgarh, MP and Rajasthan, the BJP lost 120 or 66% of 180 seats reserved for scheduled castes, or dalits, and scheduled tribes. In 2013, it had won 77% of these seats.
The Congress meanwhile won 111 or 62% of reserved seats this year, up from 42 seats (23%) in 2013.
In Chhattisgarh, where 31% of the population is Adivasi, or from scheduled tribes–the highest concentration among India’s large states–the BJP’s popularity in 29 tribal-dominated constituencies further dwindled from 2013.
Seats for scheduled castes (13% of the population) and scheduled tribes together account for 43% of the state assembly’s 90 seats.
In tribal-dominated constituencies, the incumbent party–in power for 15 years to 2018, with Raman Singh the party’s longest-running chief minister–had won four reserved seats (14%), seven fewer than in 2013 when it had won 11. In 2008, the BJP had won 19 scheduled-tribe seats.
In contrast, the Congress won a record high of 24 scheduled-tribe seats–more than the BJP has ever won in these constituencies and six more than the 18 seats it had won in 2013. In 2008, the Congress had won 10 seats.
In an indication of tribal disaffection against incumbent MLAs, in 12 of 29 seats reserved for STs in Chhattisgarh, BJP lost nine and the Congress lost three seats. Janata Congress Chhattisgarh won one seat.
The BJP failed to retain its hold over Chhattisgarh’s assembly constituencies reserved for scheduled castes. Of 10 seats reserved for scheduled castes, the party won two, down from nine it had won in 2013, results showed. The Congress won six, up one from 2013.
These election results echo our findings from travelling across India’s tribal heartland in November 2018. The state’s failure to settle forest land claims led to tension roiling in tribal dominated areas, IndiaSpend reported on November 20, 2018, and this was reflected in the performance of incumbents in scheduled-tribe constituencies.
Of 887,665 title claims, Chhattisgarh’s government issued 416,359 titles across 2.7 million acres, which is 7.8% of the state’s area or 18% of its forest area, according to our analysis of title data. Experts further believe nearly half the tribal population has not even demanded their rights yet. Community forest rights–central to the agency of Adivasi tribes, as they recognise the authority of the gram sabha (village council) to protect, manage and conserve traditional forests–account for 4.4% or 18,178 of the titles distributed.
In MP, where tribals account for 21% of the population and scheduled castes 16%, the BJP recorded its worst performance in these constituencies, losing 26 of 82 reserved seats (32%). The Congress gained 28 scheduled caste and scheduled tribe seats over 2013, its best performance in a decade.
The BJP won 16 of 47 seats reserved for STs, losing its hold over 15 seats from 2013, when it had won 31. In 2008, the BJP had won 29 seats.
The Congress has won 29 seats–after winning 15 seats in 2013, and 17 in 2008.
Of 35 seats reserved for scheduled castes, the BJP won 17 seats, 11 down from the 28 it had won in 2013, and eight fewer than the 25 seats it had won in 2008. The Congress won 18 of these seats, up from four in 2013 and nine in 2008.
In Rajasthan, 59 seats–or 30% of 200 assembly seats–are reserved for scheduled castes and scheduled tribes.
Of 25 seats reserved for Adivasis, the BJP won in 10 constituencies, the Congress in 13. The BJP is down eight seats over the previous election, when it won 18 scheduled-tribe seats. In 2013, the Congress won four seats reserved for Adivasis.
Among 34 scheduled-caste seats, the BJP won 11–the lowest in a decade–down 21 from 2013, when it won 32 seats, it’s highest in a decade. In 2008, it won 14 of these seats.
After losing all seats reserved for scheduled castes in 2013, the Congress won 21 in 2018, three more than the 18 seats it had won in 2008.