• About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertisements
  • Contact
Saturday, February 23, 2019
No Result
View All Result
NewsIn.Asia
27 °c
Colombo
  • Top Story
  • Around South Asia
    • Afghanistan
    • Bangladesh
    • China
    • India
    • Maldives
    • Myanmar
    • Nepal
    • Pakistan
    • Sri Lanka
  • World
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Travel
  • Arts
  • Cinema
  • Music
  • Offbeat
  • Interviews
  • Top Story
  • Around South Asia
    • Afghanistan
    • Bangladesh
    • China
    • India
    • Maldives
    • Myanmar
    • Nepal
    • Pakistan
    • Sri Lanka
  • World
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Travel
  • Arts
  • Cinema
  • Music
  • Offbeat
  • Interviews
No Result
View All Result
NewsIn.Asia
No Result
View All Result
Home Business

Pakistan army is a paradox: It is both professional and political

by Editor
September 8, 2018
in Business, Pakistan, Top Story, Uncategorized
0 0
0
Pakistan army is a paradox: It is both professional and political
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

By P.K.Balachandran/DailyFT

Colombo, September 7: The Pakistan army is a paradox. On the one hand, it is a professional outfit run along professional and “bureaucratic” lines. But on the other, it is a highly politicized organization in as much as it exercises decisive control over Pakistan’s political system whether it is in the seat of power as a result of a coup or it is in the barracks with civilians holding the reins of power.

“This is a highly ‘professional’ army in some respects, and remarkably ‘unprofessional’ in yet others. The very same individuals perform both its military–technical and political–interventionist activities,” say Paul Staniland, Adnan Naseemullah and Ahsan Butt in their recent paper entitled “Pakistan’s Military Elite” (https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/01402390.2018.1497487?scroll=top&needAccess=true&).

This is achieved by the fusion of internal bureaucratic discipline with placement of recently retired elites in positions of civilian power, the authors say. The accent is on “recently retired officers” because their ties with the military are the closest. They can be counted on to promote the army’s interest in the civilian institutions they are working in.

The Pakistan army is thus different from armies of many other countries, especially the Western democracies, where the army is not only under tight civilian control but is in no way involved in exercising any civilian authority.

Sure, the Pakistan army has been in and out of power. But it has never ceased to count politically. It has always seen that the “national interest”, as conceived by it, is served by civilian governments. A recalcitrant government would be overthrown.

Bureaucratic Institution

Staniland and his colleagues say that there is “strong evidence of high levels of bureaucratic institutionalization (as per Max Weber’s definition of bureaucracy) eand professionalism within the Pakistan Army. “

“The rules within the organization seem to be generally followed, with limited factionalism and consistent promotion pathways. There is a stark contrast between this cohesive, rational–bureaucratic organization and other political militaries racked by internal fratricide, plagued by factional rivalries, or vulnerable to divide-and-rule strategies by ruling elites, like those in 1960s Nigeria, 1970s Bangladesh, or 1990s Indonesia.”

The Pakistan army’s image as a well organized, internally consistent and stable force is one of the sources of its political credibility and strength. In the midst of political chaos and infighting in Pakistan, the army stands out as a unique institution, a model which other institutions will do well to follow.

This gives the army moral authority among Pakistanis. Though the people have, from time to time, rejected military regimes and struggled for civilian democratic rule, they have also not been averse to letting the army set the national house in order in times of chaos.

Corps Commanders

The Corps Commanders, headed by the Chief of Army Staff (COAS), constitute the core of the Pakistan army. It is this body which makes all the key decisions, both military and political. Its membership is not based on the Chief’s personal fancies but on bureaucratic principles.

The path to the post of Corps Commander is well laid out and traversed consistently as in a bureaucracy. The qualifications have changed with changing needs but the path to it is well set and predictable at any given time.

As a social group too, the Corps Commanders are well integrated. At the time of Staniland’s study, 55% were from Punjab and 21% from Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa (KPK). Only 3% were from Sindh, 3% from Kashmir, and 2% from Balochistan. Age-wise too, the Corps Commanders are a homogenous group largely between 54 and 58. They also retire more or less at the same time.

“The general clustering of the retirement age suggests an institutionalized organization. In personalized or factionalized militaries, we would expect much higher variance, with favored officers – the son-in-law of the dictator, members of the dominant faction – being promoted early and often,” Staniland points out.

The Corps Commanders have more or less the same service background. 66% are from the infantry, 15% from armor, 14 % from artillery, and less than 5 % from engineering or from air defense. This blend has not dramatically changed over time.

And the Pakistan army is basically an infantry army. Eight of ten army chiefs came from the infantry. This reflects the composition of the Pakistan military as whole. Presently, the army has 25 divisions, of which 21 are infantry divisions.

Askari Bank is a Pakistan Army WelfareTrust bank and is a public limited company listed in the stock exchange

Good Retirement Benefits

A key reason for the stability of the institution at the top level is the assurance of good retirement benefits, the researchers say. Retired Generals and other senior officers are seamlessly accommodated in government institutions and in the many “Fauji” or army owned commercial enterprises such as Mari Gas, Fauji Fertilizer, Fauji Cement, Askari Cement and Askari Bank. Over 60% of Corps Commanders worked for the government immediately after retiring. Personnel in these positions change roughly every three years, providing opportunities for the newly retired.

The Fauji enterprises are owned by the Army Welfare Trust administered by the GHQ. But they are public limited companies listed in the stock exchange. They are as much part of the army structure as they are part of the civilian structure and represent the military-civilian linkage. Close and continuous involvement with civilian activities contribute to the army’s influence over civilian life.

“The placement of retired elites has not shifted much across periods of military and civilian rule since the late 1980s: even when back in the barracks, the army has deep reach into the economy and bureaucracy,” the authors point out.

Land and Housing

The Pakistan army is involved in acquisition of land both to provide retiring officers with residential property and to participate in the lucrative property market in Pakistan, the researchers say.

“Retired officers often own more than one property; the pyramidal structure of the Army is operative when it comes to land perks. After 15 years of service, officers are entitled to one residential plot, after 25 a second, after 28 a third, and after 32 a fourth.”

“ Thus, selling or renting housing to civilians is a common practice, and military officers and civilians commingle in most of the ostensibly military housing companies, which have become some of the most elite locations in urban Pakistan

The stability the military system and its consistent and lucrative links with civilian Pakistan through commercial activities obviate the need for entering politics to make a living after retirement, the authors contend.

Education

Pakistan army lays great emphasis on the education of its officer cadre. Corps Commanders are either graduates or post graduates. Commandants of the Pakistan Military Academy (PMA) and the Command and Staff College often become Corps Commanders. And this is increasingly so because the modern army needs leaders with skills other than those acquired on the battle field.

“Of the 54 officers who left service in or prior to 2000 about whom we have prior command data, 35% held a General Head Quarters (GHQ) staff position; 33% held a combat formation command, and 15% commanded an army school. By contrast, of the 96 retirees after 2000, GHQ positions accounted for 48% of pre-corps positions, heads of army schools for 16%, and a combat formation command for only 11%,” the paper says, showing the increasing importance being given to academic attainments post-2000.

The post-retirement jobs in the Fauji companies also need qualifications as these are commercial enterprises and answerable to shareholders.

Inter-Services Intelligence

Even the shadowy Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI), the main intelligence arm of the Pakistani State, is as bureaucratically organized as the rest of the military and is inextricably linked with the army structure. It is not a closed and autonomous unit as ISI officers enter from other units and exit to join combat or staff units.

Like the rest of the army, the ISI is also a Pashtun–Punjabi outfit. But the ISI commanding elite are more broadly spread across army units than the Corp Commanders: 41% are from the infantry, 23% from artillery, 18% from armor, and 18% from engineering or signals.

(The featured image at the top shows the Pakistan Chief of Army Staff Gen.Qmar Bajwa addressing the Corps Commanders)

Recommended

  • Recommend
Hasina sweeps Bangladesh polls as her father Mujib did in the landmark 1970 elections

Hasina sweeps Bangladesh polls as her father Mujib did in the landmark 1970 elections

2 months ago
Sri Lanka’s China funded Port City completes land reclamation amounting to 269 hectares

Sri Lanka’s China funded Port City completes land reclamation amounting to 269 hectares

1 month ago
Chinese spacecraft to give clearer idea of geological and mineral map of moon’s far side

Chinese spacecraft to give clearer idea of geological and mineral map of moon’s far side

2 months ago
Governor’s recipe to end military-people conflict over release of land in North Lanka

Governor’s recipe to end military-people conflict over release of land in North Lanka

2 weeks ago
Rohingya rehabilitation work suffers from dis-junction and fatigue across Asia

Rohingya rehabilitation work suffers from dis-junction and fatigue across Asia

1 week ago
Load More

Popular News

    About Us

    NewsIn.Asia is a South Asian website, operating from Colombo and accessed by readers worldwide. It offers its readers timely, indepth and comprehensive coverage of South Asian news, views and analyses.

    Follow US

    • Modi hugs Saudi Crown Prince on arrival expects huge investments in the energy sector - New Delhi February 19 Agencies New Indian Express In a special gesture Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday received at the airport here Saudi Arabia s Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman signifying importance India attaches to the visit by the leader of the powerful Gulf nation The View more at NewsIn Asia
    • Pakistan PM neither condemned the Pulwama attack nor condoled the deaths India points out - Pakistan claims to be the greatest victim of terrorism This is far from the truth Pakistan is the nerve center of terrorism the Indian External Affairs Ministry said View more at NewsIn Asia
    • One pilot killed as two Indian aerobatic aircraft collide over Bengaluru - The defense ministry confirmed that two Hawk aircraft of the Surya Kiran Aerobatic Display Team had crashed near the Yelahanka Air Force Base View more at NewsIn Asia
    • Ex-Maldivian President Yameen in Maafushi prison in money laundering case - Male February 19 Avas Former Maldivian President Abdulla Yameen has been taken to Maafushi Prison in accordance with Criminal Court s orders to keep the former President in custody until the end of his money laundering trial Yameen appeared in the Criminal Court here on Monday View more at NewsIn Asia
    • Tamil Nadu parties AIADMK and PMK seal electoral pact Talks with BJP on - Chennai February 19 AIR After lengthy negotiations the Pattali Makkal Katchi PMK has signed an alliance with the ruling All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam AIADMK for the upcoming Lok Sabha Elections The pact was signed between PMK founder S Ramadoss and AIADMK coordinator and View more at NewsIn Asia
    • Pakistan PM warns of immediate retaliation if India becomes adventurous - We all know that it is easy to start a war but very difficult to end And we do not know where it all will lead to Premier Imran Khan said in a TV address View more at NewsIn Asia
    • Sri Lankan spices to enter new global markets in 2019 - Colombo Feb 19 Sri Lanka s lucrative spice industry is targeting a revenue of US 500 million dollars in 2019 following its entry into new global markets as well as increasing exports of pepper cloves and nutmeg local media reported Tuesday To achieve this target the spice View more at NewsIn Asia
    • Indian aerobatic jets collide and crash pilots eject - Bengaluru February 19 NDTV Two jets of the Indian Air Force s Suryakiran Aerobatic Team crashed in Bengaluru a day before the Aero India show begins in the city The accident took place during a rehearsal session ahead of the mega show The pilots of the two jets have ejected safely in View more at NewsIn Asia
    • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Advertisements
    • Contact

    © 2018-19 NewsIn.Asia - Lovingly Maintained by DigitalArc.

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Top Story
    • Around South Asia
      • Afghanistan
      • Bangladesh
      • China
      • India
      • Maldives
      • Myanmar
      • Nepal
      • Pakistan
      • Sri Lanka
    • World
    • Business
    • Sports
    • Travel
    • Arts
    • Cinema
    • Music
    • Offbeat
    • Interviews

    © 2018-19 NewsIn.Asia - Lovingly Maintained by DigitalArc.

    Login to your account below

    Forgotten Password? Sign Up

    Fill the forms bellow to register

    All fields are required. Log In

    Retrieve your password

    Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

    Log In