• Latest
  • Trending

Issues in implementing reservation for the poor among India’s forward castes

January 12, 2019
Electricity

Power cut schedule today in Sri Lanka: 19th August

August 18, 2022
alcohol

Japan urges its young people to drink more to boost economy

August 18, 2022
Subscribe to our Telegram channel for the latest updates from around the world. Image credits - Jinan Times

Fish tested amid Xiamen covid outbreak in China

August 18, 2022
FIFA World Cup

FIFA sells 2.45 million tickets for Qatar World Cup

August 18, 2022
Oil

Myanmar buys Russian oil as emerging markets take shunned supply

August 18, 2022
dollar

Amnesty period announced to deposit/sell foreign currency in the hands of public

August 18, 2022
Veteran journalist Sugeeswara Senadhira appointed Lankan Prime Minister’s Media Advisor

Veteran journalist Sugeeswara Senadhira appointed Lankan Prime Minister’s Media Advisor

August 18, 2022
Austria donates essential medicines to Sri Lanka

Austria donates essential medicines to Sri Lanka

August 18, 2022
Laugfs gas

Laugfs gas price reduced

August 18, 2022
Sri Lankan passports

Special counter to issue passports for overseas jobs

August 17, 2022
Inflation

UK inflation tops 10%, highest since 1982

August 17, 2022
T20 World Cup in 2026

India and Sri Lanka will jointly host the T20 World Cup in 2026

August 17, 2022
  • About Us
  • Advertisements
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
Friday, August 19, 2022
No Result
View All Result
NewsIn.Asia
  • Home
  • Around South Asia
    • All
    • Afghanistan
    • Bangladesh
    • Bhutan
    • China
    • India
    • Maldives
    • Myanmar
    • Nepal
    • Pakistan
    • Sri Lanka
    Electricity

    Power cut schedule today in Sri Lanka: 19th August

    Subscribe to our Telegram channel for the latest updates from around the world. Image credits - Jinan Times

    Fish tested amid Xiamen covid outbreak in China

    Oil

    Myanmar buys Russian oil as emerging markets take shunned supply

    dollar

    Amnesty period announced to deposit/sell foreign currency in the hands of public

    Veteran journalist Sugeeswara Senadhira appointed Lankan Prime Minister’s Media Advisor

    Veteran journalist Sugeeswara Senadhira appointed Lankan Prime Minister’s Media Advisor

    Austria donates essential medicines to Sri Lanka

    Austria donates essential medicines to Sri Lanka

    Laugfs gas

    Laugfs gas price reduced

    Sri Lankan passports

    Special counter to issue passports for overseas jobs

    T20 World Cup in 2026

    India and Sri Lanka will jointly host the T20 World Cup in 2026

  • World
    • All
    • Japan
    • Russia
    • United Kingdom
    • United States
    alcohol

    Japan urges its young people to drink more to boost economy

    Oil

    Myanmar buys Russian oil as emerging markets take shunned supply

    Inflation

    UK inflation tops 10%, highest since 1982

    Footage posted by the fire brigade on Twitter showed large plumes of smoke coming from under the railway arch, which it said was "completely alight". (Photo: Twitter/@LondonFire)

    Large blaze in central London railway arch under control – fire service

    Multiple bomb and arson attacks rock southern Thailand

    Multiple bomb, arson attacks rock Thailand’s south

    Elon Musk

    Elon Musk says he is buying Manchester United

    Britain launches trade system for developing countries including Sri Lanka

    Britain launches trade system for developing countries including Sri Lanka

    A view shows a bionic hand developed by COVVI, at Quayside Business Park in Leeds, Britain. (Photo: Reuters)

    Bionic hand can be updated with new gestures, anytime, anywhere

    Kenya's Deputy President and presidential candidate William Ruto of Kenya Kwanza (Kenya first) political party coalition delivers a speech the rally on the final day of campaigning at the Nyayo National Stadium in Nairobi on August 6, 2022.

    William Ruto defeats Raila Odinga to win Kenyan presidency

  • Business
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Books
    • Gaming
    • Movie
    • Music
    • Series
    Raksha Bandhan to Laal Singh Chaddha: ‘Struggling’ Bollywood’s online hate problem

    Raksha Bandhan to Laal Singh Chaddha: ‘Struggling’ Bollywood’s online hate problem

    Marvel has unleashed the first look teaser of Black Panther 2.

    Black Panther Wakanda Forever: Marvel pays emotional tribute to Chadwick Boseman

    Stranger Things

    Netflix confirms ‘Stranger Things’ spinoff and play

    Kamal Haasan's Vikram is on a rampage.

    Kamal Haasan’s Vikram is the highest-grossing film in Singapore, UK and UAE

    Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone

    ‘Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone’ celebrates 25 magical years

    Salman Khan

    Plot to kill Bollywood actor Salman Khan revealed

    Shah Rukh Khan's Jawaan, to be directed by Atlee, to scheduled for June 2023 release. (Photo: Twitter)

    Shah Rukh Khan announces new film ‘Jawaan’

    Chchutir diner Gaan by Bangladeshi singer Nondita

    Chchutir diner Gaan by Bangladeshi singer Nondita

    Song “Bechain Nazar Betaab Jigar”. Talat Mahmood. Film “Yasmin” 1955

    Song “Bechain Nazar Betaab Jigar”. Talat Mahmood. Film “Yasmin” 1955

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health
    • Science
    • Travel
    Austria donates essential medicines to Sri Lanka

    Austria donates essential medicines to Sri Lanka

    Digital. Image credits - Scott Graham @homajob / Unsplash

    In remote work and tech companies, job titles have gotten longer – and fancier

    Walk. Image credits - Arek Adeoye @areksan / Unsplash

    Why even 2 minutes of walking after a meal will improve your health

    Cheeseburger. Image credits - Alamy / BBC

    McDonald’s puts up price of cheeseburger for first time in 14 years

    WHO declares rapidly spreading monkeypox outbreak a global health emergency

    WHO declares rapidly spreading monkeypox outbreak a global health emergency

    Sushmita Sen. Image credits - Getty Images

    Sushmita Sen: Why ‘gold digger’ jibe caused outrage

    Honey. Image credits - Mariana Ibanez / Unsplash

    7 unique health benefits of honey

    alcohol

    Alcohol is never healthy for people under 40, study finds

    world’s happiest countries in 2022

    List of world’s happiest countries in 2022

    Emirates

    Emirates statement on operations at London Heathrow

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
  • Tech
    A view shows a bionic hand developed by COVVI, at Quayside Business Park in Leeds, Britain. (Photo: Reuters)

    Bionic hand can be updated with new gestures, anytime, anywhere

    FILE PHOTO: The Netflix logo is pictured on a television in this illustration photograph taken in Encinitas, California, U.S., January 18, 2017. REUTERS/Mike Blake/File Photo

    Disney overtakes Netflix in race for subscribers

    Samsung unveiled its new Galaxy Z Flip 4 and Z Fold 4 phones on Aug 10, 2022. (Photo: Samsung)

    5 things to know about Samsung’s new Galaxy Z Flip 4 and Galaxy Z Fold 4 foldable smartphones

    Image: WhatsApp

    WhatsApp’s new update makes it easier to avoid your friends

    Snapchat. Image credits - May Gauthier @maygauthier / Unsplash

    Snap launches tools for parents to monitor teens’ contacts

    FILE PHOTO: A 3D printed Google logo is seen in this illustration taken April 12, 2020. REUTERS/Dado Ruvic/Illustration/File Photo

    Thousands of users around the world report Google outage

    Trending Tags

    • Sillicon Valley
    • Climate Change
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
    • Golden Globes
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Mr. Robot
  • Coronavirus
  • Videos
  • Home
  • Around South Asia
    • All
    • Afghanistan
    • Bangladesh
    • Bhutan
    • China
    • India
    • Maldives
    • Myanmar
    • Nepal
    • Pakistan
    • Sri Lanka
    Electricity

    Power cut schedule today in Sri Lanka: 19th August

    Subscribe to our Telegram channel for the latest updates from around the world. Image credits - Jinan Times

    Fish tested amid Xiamen covid outbreak in China

    Oil

    Myanmar buys Russian oil as emerging markets take shunned supply

    dollar

    Amnesty period announced to deposit/sell foreign currency in the hands of public

    Veteran journalist Sugeeswara Senadhira appointed Lankan Prime Minister’s Media Advisor

    Veteran journalist Sugeeswara Senadhira appointed Lankan Prime Minister’s Media Advisor

    Austria donates essential medicines to Sri Lanka

    Austria donates essential medicines to Sri Lanka

    Laugfs gas

    Laugfs gas price reduced

    Sri Lankan passports

    Special counter to issue passports for overseas jobs

    T20 World Cup in 2026

    India and Sri Lanka will jointly host the T20 World Cup in 2026

  • World
    • All
    • Japan
    • Russia
    • United Kingdom
    • United States
    alcohol

    Japan urges its young people to drink more to boost economy

    Oil

    Myanmar buys Russian oil as emerging markets take shunned supply

    Inflation

    UK inflation tops 10%, highest since 1982

    Footage posted by the fire brigade on Twitter showed large plumes of smoke coming from under the railway arch, which it said was "completely alight". (Photo: Twitter/@LondonFire)

    Large blaze in central London railway arch under control – fire service

    Multiple bomb and arson attacks rock southern Thailand

    Multiple bomb, arson attacks rock Thailand’s south

    Elon Musk

    Elon Musk says he is buying Manchester United

    Britain launches trade system for developing countries including Sri Lanka

    Britain launches trade system for developing countries including Sri Lanka

    A view shows a bionic hand developed by COVVI, at Quayside Business Park in Leeds, Britain. (Photo: Reuters)

    Bionic hand can be updated with new gestures, anytime, anywhere

    Kenya's Deputy President and presidential candidate William Ruto of Kenya Kwanza (Kenya first) political party coalition delivers a speech the rally on the final day of campaigning at the Nyayo National Stadium in Nairobi on August 6, 2022.

    William Ruto defeats Raila Odinga to win Kenyan presidency

  • Business
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Books
    • Gaming
    • Movie
    • Music
    • Series
    Raksha Bandhan to Laal Singh Chaddha: ‘Struggling’ Bollywood’s online hate problem

    Raksha Bandhan to Laal Singh Chaddha: ‘Struggling’ Bollywood’s online hate problem

    Marvel has unleashed the first look teaser of Black Panther 2.

    Black Panther Wakanda Forever: Marvel pays emotional tribute to Chadwick Boseman

    Stranger Things

    Netflix confirms ‘Stranger Things’ spinoff and play

    Kamal Haasan's Vikram is on a rampage.

    Kamal Haasan’s Vikram is the highest-grossing film in Singapore, UK and UAE

    Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone

    ‘Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone’ celebrates 25 magical years

    Salman Khan

    Plot to kill Bollywood actor Salman Khan revealed

    Shah Rukh Khan's Jawaan, to be directed by Atlee, to scheduled for June 2023 release. (Photo: Twitter)

    Shah Rukh Khan announces new film ‘Jawaan’

    Chchutir diner Gaan by Bangladeshi singer Nondita

    Chchutir diner Gaan by Bangladeshi singer Nondita

    Song “Bechain Nazar Betaab Jigar”. Talat Mahmood. Film “Yasmin” 1955

    Song “Bechain Nazar Betaab Jigar”. Talat Mahmood. Film “Yasmin” 1955

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Health
    • Science
    • Travel
    Austria donates essential medicines to Sri Lanka

    Austria donates essential medicines to Sri Lanka

    Digital. Image credits - Scott Graham @homajob / Unsplash

    In remote work and tech companies, job titles have gotten longer – and fancier

    Walk. Image credits - Arek Adeoye @areksan / Unsplash

    Why even 2 minutes of walking after a meal will improve your health

    Cheeseburger. Image credits - Alamy / BBC

    McDonald’s puts up price of cheeseburger for first time in 14 years

    WHO declares rapidly spreading monkeypox outbreak a global health emergency

    WHO declares rapidly spreading monkeypox outbreak a global health emergency

    Sushmita Sen. Image credits - Getty Images

    Sushmita Sen: Why ‘gold digger’ jibe caused outrage

    Honey. Image credits - Mariana Ibanez / Unsplash

    7 unique health benefits of honey

    alcohol

    Alcohol is never healthy for people under 40, study finds

    world’s happiest countries in 2022

    List of world’s happiest countries in 2022

    Emirates

    Emirates statement on operations at London Heathrow

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
  • Tech
    A view shows a bionic hand developed by COVVI, at Quayside Business Park in Leeds, Britain. (Photo: Reuters)

    Bionic hand can be updated with new gestures, anytime, anywhere

    FILE PHOTO: The Netflix logo is pictured on a television in this illustration photograph taken in Encinitas, California, U.S., January 18, 2017. REUTERS/Mike Blake/File Photo

    Disney overtakes Netflix in race for subscribers

    Samsung unveiled its new Galaxy Z Flip 4 and Z Fold 4 phones on Aug 10, 2022. (Photo: Samsung)

    5 things to know about Samsung’s new Galaxy Z Flip 4 and Galaxy Z Fold 4 foldable smartphones

    Image: WhatsApp

    WhatsApp’s new update makes it easier to avoid your friends

    Snapchat. Image credits - May Gauthier @maygauthier / Unsplash

    Snap launches tools for parents to monitor teens’ contacts

    FILE PHOTO: A 3D printed Google logo is seen in this illustration taken April 12, 2020. REUTERS/Dado Ruvic/Illustration/File Photo

    Thousands of users around the world report Google outage

    Trending Tags

    • Sillicon Valley
    • Climate Change
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
    • Golden Globes
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Mr. Robot
  • Coronavirus
  • Videos
NewsIn.Asia
No Result
View All Result
Home Around South Asia India

Issues in implementing reservation for the poor among India’s forward castes

Editor by Editor
January 12, 2019
in India, Politics, Top Story
Reading Time: 4 mins read
2 0
A A
Share on WhatsApp

By P.K.Balachandran/DailyFT

Colombo January 12: Earlier this week, the Narendra Modi government got the Indian parliament to pass the 124 th. Constitutional Amendment bill to give 10% reservation for the “poor” among the “Forward Castes” or Communities in the country.

This was to address a long-standing complaint from these communities that, in the existing reservation system for jobs in government institutions and places in government educational institutions, the Forward Castes have no quota, while the Scheduled Castes (ST), Scheduled Tribes (ST) and Other Backward Classes (OBC) each have a fixed quota.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Forward Castes and communities are classified as the “General Category” and government jobs and places in educational institutions are given to them on the basis of competition open to all communities.

The Indian constitutional reservation system with quotas for SCs, STs and OBCs was instituted to address the primordial social and educational inequalities which were based on the institution of caste, a hierarchical Hindu social and economic order based on birth.

In most States (provinces) the communities identified as “forward” were the Brahmin, Kshatriya and Vaishya castes and also certain peasant castes which are numerically, economically ,politically and socially dominant. Among the latter are castes such as the Jats, Marathas, Patidars and Vellalas.

For over 3000 years, the non-forward  castes, now classified as  OBCs, SCs and STs, were oppressed and denied opportunities for education and progress, while the Forward Castes forged ahead.

However, as a result of some socio-political movements,  independent India drew up a constitution which gave the SCs  (previously dubbed untouchable) 15% reservation, and the STs 7.5%. Then, in 1989-1990, the government set apart 27% for the OBCs. Some States like Tamil Nadu had already done so and 68% of the places were in the reserved category.

To restrain governments from expanding the reserved category to meet political ends through vote bank politics, the Supreme Court ruled that reservation should not exceed 50% of the total places up for grabs.

The reservation system has come under fire periodically. Many castes have clamored to be included in the reserved category. The most Forward Castes have been totally against reservation as it militates against the operation of merit. Others have said that an economic criterion should be introduced to take out the rich from the list so that the facilities go to the really needy.

Central and State government have tried to introduce an economic criterion so that the poor among the Forward Castes benefit. But the judiciary would always disallow these moves because the constitution does not recognize reservation based on economic criteria. Quite rightly, the constitution only recognizes primordial (and still existing) “social disability” as the basis of deep rooted prejudice and of denial opportunities.

Some States included Forward Castes in the Backward Class category. But this was frowned upon by the courts. Some States introduced reservation on the basis of poverty but the constitutionality of these could be questioned.

Agitations over reservation have always turned violent

Arguments Against Economic Criterion

Arguments against reservation based on economic criteria are many:  One of them is that wealth is not automatically translated into social status in traditional societies as in India. Markers of high status here are accessibility to certain institutions and spaces like the temple, the dining area, types of work, government jobs of a particular kind, and access to education of a particular kind. Possession of wealth is no guarantee that the possessor has access to such places of status. It is often said that a poor Brahmin youth has greater access to the socially valued places than a wealthy person from a depressed caste.

However, as democracy spreads, education and jobs which confer high status begin to be sought by Backward Castes/SCs/STs as well as the Forward Castes. The wars over reservation are over a share of this cake.

The second argument against economic criteria is that wealth is not static, unlike caste. One can acquire wealth and lose wealth. One can be poor today and wealthy tomorrow. But caste is static. One is born into a caste and is stuck with it lifelong. In a caste society such an affiliation can be quite debilitating.

The third objection to economic criteria is that it is difficult to determine and quantify poverty because notions of poverty vary from time to time depending on changing economic circumstances and value systems. And yardsticks to measure poverty have kept changing.

According to the World Bank, 270,000 000 Indians or one fifth of Indians are poor. 75% of rural households in India have a monthly income of less than Rs 5,000 (US$ 79). Rs.5,000 per month per household with an average household size of five would also mean an income of Rs.33 per person per day in the rural areas.

More than 70 million rural households face some form of exclusion, either from assets or socio-economic benefits, according to data released by the Socio-Economic Caste Census (SECC). India Spend recently reported how rural India has more illiterate people than the population of Indonesia.

Because the idea of poverty varies even from State to State, for the purpose of reservation, the government has left it to the State governments to decide on the markers of poverty.

Challenges in Implementation

Be that as it may, a question that still remains to be answered is how governments are going to fill the 10% quota for the poor. The majority of Indians of most castes are poor. And being poor they cannot get the right kind of education and training to fill the middle and higher level jobs in the government.

And governments in India are still small, with a total workforce of only 15 million. Therefore, governments can accommodate only a small fraction of the 13 million youths who join the work force every year. And reservation applies only to government institutions.

Overall in India, job creation has averaged only 500,000 per year according to Labor Bureau statistics. Trade unions also complain that governments have been increasingly resorting to contractual employment abandoning permanent employment.

And governments have not even been filling posts which ought to go to the reserved categories. According to data secured through the Right to Information Act, only 9040 out of the 79483 employees in select ministries and departments of the Central government, were from the OBC.

This being the case, how will 10% reservation for the poor of the Forward Classes help? What purpose will it serve other than giving Prime Minister Modi  a propaganda devise to help him recover from the shock defeats his Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) received in the crucial pre-parliamentary elections in Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh.

Constitutionality in Question

Furthermore, the reservation act is yet to pass the test of constitutionality in the Supreme Court. As soon as the Act was passed, “Youth For Equality”, an NGO,  sought the quashing of the bill, saying that economic criterion cannot be the sole basis for reservation. Also, reservation on economic grounds cannot be limited to the General Category (Forward Castes). And the 50% ceiling limit set by the Supreme Court cannot be breached.

(The featured image at the top is that of Patidars agitating for reservation in Gujarat) 

Related Posts

T20 World Cup in 2026
Around The World

India and Sri Lanka will jointly host the T20 World Cup in 2026

August 17, 2022
File photo of Jacqueline Fernandez | PTI
Around South Asia

Jacqueline Fernandez to be named accused in ₹200 crore extortion case: Report

August 17, 2022
Wickremesinghe reiterates Sri Lanka’s commitment to the One-China policy
Around South Asia

Lanka round-up: No extension of Emergency after August 18: President

August 18, 2022
Indian Railway
Around South Asia

Man wins 22-year legal battle against Indian Railway over 25 cents

August 16, 2022
How India came out of the 1991 economic crisis
Economy

How India came out of the 1991 economic crisis

August 18, 2022
India gifts Dornier maritime reconnaissance aircraft to Sri Lankan air force
Around South Asia

India gifts Dornier maritime reconnaissance aircraft to Sri Lankan air force

August 18, 2022
  • Electricity

    Power cut schedule today in Sri Lanka: 19th August

    49503 shares
    Share 19814 Tweet 12370
  • Registration open for National Fuel Pass

    6550 shares
    Share 2657 Tweet 1622
  • Foreign Exchange Rates from Central Bank of Sri Lanka; USD, GBP, EUR, SGD, CAD

    1408 shares
    Share 570 Tweet 349
  • WATCH : Yohani’s first live performance in India

    785 shares
    Share 327 Tweet 191
  • Power interruption schedule released: Check your area power cut time

    734 shares
    Share 312 Tweet 176
  • About Us
  • Advertisements
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact

© 2022 All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Around South Asia
    • Afghanistan
    • Bangladesh
    • Bhutan
    • China
    • India
    • Maldives
    • Myanmar
    • Nepal
    • Pakistan
    • Sri Lanka
  • Around The World
  • Breaking News
  • Business
    • Exchange
  • Climate Change
  • Governance
    • Crime
    • Diplomacy
    • Defense
    • Human Rights
    • Politics
    • Strategic Affairs
  • Lifestyle
    • Books
    • Entertainment
      • Arts
      • Cinema
      • Gaming
      • Music
      • Movie
      • Series
      • TV
    • Health
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Travel
  • Culture
    • Ethnicity
    • Gender
  • Development news
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Environment
  • Coronavirus
  • History
  • National
  • Offbeat
    • Media
    • Music and arts across South Asia
  • Recommended
    • Headlines
    • Highlights
    • Top Picture
    • Top Story
  • Religion
  • Science
  • Sports
    • Football
    • Cricket
      • LPL
      • IPL
    • Tennis
    • Formula 1
    • NBA
  • Tech
    • Instagram
  • United Nations
  • Weather
  • World
    • Japan
    • Russia
    • United States
  • Videos

© 2022 All rights reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

mersin eskort -

Meritroyalbet

-
Jojobet
- Süperbetin - eskisehir escort -

https://www.vudols.com/

- Sağlık Personeli - istanbul avukat